The roles of the combatants, the superpowers and the UN

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how local states, the superpowers and the UN shaped how conflicts developed over time.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the roles of different actors in the development of conflicts over time

Make a guess

The USSR armed Egypt and Syria, and the USA armed Israel. Do you think the superpowers controlled their allies?

  1. Yes, the wars were planned in Washington or Moscow and the states obeyed.
  2. No, because the superpowers kept their distance and stayed out of the region.
  3. No, the states made the key decisions; superpowers armed and restrained them.
Show the answer

No, the states made the key decisions; superpowers armed and restrained them.

Clients chose war and peace themselves. Superpowers could limit them, as the USA did over Suez in 1956.

The combatant states made the key decisions for war and peace. The superpowers armed and restrained them, and the UN managed ceasefires and borders.

The combatant states drove events. Arab states chose war in 1948 and 1973. Nasser's moves set off the 1967 war, and Israel struck first in 1956 and 1967. Sadat and Begin chose peace in 1977-1979.

The USSR armed Egypt and Syria from 1955, which made new wars possible. The USA became Israel's main arms supplier after 1967. Each superpower was drawn in to protect its client.

Yet the superpowers also held their clients back. In 1956-1957 the USA pressed Britain, France and Israel to withdraw, and they did. In 1973 both superpowers pressed for a ceasefire to avoid a direct clash. The USA then became the essential mediator.

The UN made the partition plan and arranged armistices and ceasefires. It set the terms for peace in Resolution 242. Its peacekeepers kept borders quiet for long periods.

But the UN depended on the consent of the combatants and the support of the superpowers. It could not prevent wars or enforce Resolution 242.

Soviet arms
To Egypt and Syria from 1955.
US support
Israel's main arms supplier after 1967.
US mediation
Kissinger and Carter, 1973-1979.

Worked example: Eisenhower presses Israel, 20 February 1957

Israel would not leave Gaza and Sharm el-Sheikh without guarantees. On 20 February 1957 President Eisenhower spoke on radio and television. He asked whether a nation that "attacks and occupies foreign territory in the face of United Nations disapproval" should set conditions for leaving.

  1. Superpower: the UN, he said, "has no choice but to exert pressure upon Israel to comply".
  2. Combatant: Israel agreed to go. On 8 March the UN reported that its forces had left Gaza and Sharm el-Sheikh.
  3. UN: UNEF moved into the posts Israel left, so a neutral force held the line.
  4. Judgement: the USA could restrain even a friendly state when it chose to. The UN then made the result last.

Watch out for this

The superpowers controlled their Middle Eastern allies.

Clients often acted on their own. Nasser in 1967 and Sadat in 1973 made choices that their patrons did not control.

Check your understanding

How did the USA restrain its allies in 1956?

  1. It used financial pressure to force Britain to withdraw from Suez.
  2. It vetoed UNEF so that Britain had to negotiate.
  3. It sent troops to fight Israel until Israel agreed to leave Sinai.
Show the answer

It used financial pressure to force Britain to withdraw from Suez.

Right. Britain needed US support for the pound.

Check your understanding

In 1957 Eisenhower publicly pressed Israel to leave Gaza and Sinai, and UNEF took over the posts it left. What does this show about how the actors worked together?

  1. US pressure moved Israel; the UN then held the ground it left.
  2. The USSR forced Israel out by threatening war in 1957.
  3. The UN forced Israel out with UNEF's armed troops.
Show the answer

US pressure moved Israel; the UN then held the ground it left.

Right. The superpower supplied the pressure and the UN supplied the buffer.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready