What this lesson teaches
I can weigh the benefits and costs of free trade and open flows for consumers, producers and governments.
Syllabus 9570, 3.3.1(c). Globalisation, International Trade and Economic Co-operation: Benefits and costs of free trade and flows of capital and labour on:; Consumers - Prices, choice and variety of goods and services; Producers - Size of markets, degree of competition, cost of production and innovation; Government - Macroeconomic objectives (and policy choice)
I can explain why a government may sign trade agreements or protect its industries to meet its aims.
Syllabus 9570, 3.3.1(e). Globalisation, International Trade and Economic Co-operation: Governments may decide to engage in economic co-operation and trade agreements between countries or impose protectionist measures to achieve macroeconomic aims
Make a guess
Workers lose jobs because cheaper imports replace local goods. What is usually the better response for Singapore?
- Ban the imports to protect the jobs.
- Retrain and support them, and keep trade open.
- Leave it to the market, because cheaper imports help the whole country.
Show the answer
Retrain and support them, and keep trade open.
Trade raises national income overall. Targeted help for the losers keeps those gains while easing the cost to the people hit.
Openness brings large overall gains; the key is to spread them fairly and build resilience against disruption.
Trade raises national income overall, but the gains and losses are shared unevenly. A strong judgement separates the gain to the country from who gets it.
If imports cost workers their jobs, retraining and short-term income support help them more directly than lasting protection.
If the worry is a steady supply of essentials, more suppliers and stockpiles make supply safer, and the country keeps the gains from trade.
For Singapore, the usual conclusion is to stay open and keep signing trade deals. It should also raise productivity to stay competitive, and support workers who lose out.
- Principle
- Keep the gains; support those who lose.
- Resilience
- Diversify suppliers; stockpile.
Worked example: When Malaysia stopped chicken exports, 2022
From 1 June 2022, Malaysia stopped exporting chickens, to keep its own prices down. About a third of Singapore's chicken imports came from Malaysia, mostly as live birds. Singapore's food agency, SFA, pointed buyers to frozen chicken from Brazil and other sources.
- Singapore already bought chicken from several countries, so other sources could fill much of the gap.
- Buyers who wanted fresh chicken had less choice for a time.
- Growing all its chicken at home would cost far more land and money than buying from many sources.
- More suppliers target the supply risk without giving up the gains from trade.
Watch out for this
A country that bans exports of a food is trying to cut AD and fight demand-pull inflation.
The aim is to keep more of the food at home. Domestic supply rises, so the domestic price falls. It is a supply measure for one market, not a tool to cut AD.
Check your understanding
Singapore wants to secure its rice supply. Which approach fits its situation best?
- Banning rice imports, so local farms grow more of what it eats.
- Buying from many countries and keeping a stockpile.
- Growing all its rice locally.
Show the answer
Buying from many countries and keeping a stockpile.
Right. This builds resilience without costly self-sufficiency.