Arguments for protection

H2 Economics - syllabus 9570, 2026

What this lesson teaches

  • I can weigh the benefits and costs of protectionism.

    Syllabus 9570, 3.3.1(d). Globalisation, International Trade and Economic Co-operation: Benefits and costs of protectionism

Make a guess

Country A puts tariffs on Country B's goods. Country B replies with tariffs on A's exports. What happens to jobs in A's export industries?

  1. They rise, because the tariff protects A's firms.
  2. Nothing changes, because A does not tax its own exports.
  3. They may fall, as A's exports become dearer in B.
Show the answer

They may fall, as A's exports become dearer in B.

Retaliation raises the price of A's goods in B, so B buys fewer. That is one way protection costs jobs elsewhere.

Protection is sometimes argued for infant industries, jobs or strategic reasons, but the arguments are often weaker than they seem.

Infant industry: a new industry may need protection for a time, until it grows big enough to compete. This works only if it can really become competitive, and the protection ends on time.

Protecting jobs: tariffs may save jobs in industries that compete with imports, in the short run. But they raise costs for consumers and for firms that use imported inputs, and they invite retaliation.

Strategic reasons: countries may protect food, energy or defence supplies. Singapore instead keeps many suppliers and stockpiles.

For a small, open economy like Singapore, protection costs a lot. It raises the cost of the imported parts its exporters use. And other countries may hit back with tariffs on Singapore's exports.

Arguments
Infant industry, jobs, strategic supply.
Costs
Higher prices, deadweight loss, retaliation.

Worked example: Malaysia's national car

Malaysia set up Proton, its national carmaker, in 1983. Its first car, the Saga, came out in 1985, and imported cars faced much higher taxes. In 2017, with Proton struggling, China's Geely bought 49.9% of it.

  1. This was an infant-industry case: shelter Proton until it could compete.
  2. Malaysian buyers paid more for cars and had less choice.
  3. The protection lasted for decades, not a few years, and Proton still turned to a foreign partner.
  4. Infant-industry protection works best with clear targets and a set end date.

Watch out for this

To judge whether protection is a good idea, I describe tariffs, quotas and subsidies.

That lists methods. The question asks about arguments. Explain why protection might help, such as for infant industries, jobs or security, and what it costs. Then judge which side is stronger.

Check your understanding

What must be true for the infant industry argument to justify protection?

  1. It must be able to become competitive, and protection must be temporary.
  2. The industry must already produce at lower cost than foreign rivals.
  3. The industry must employ many workers who would struggle to find other jobs.
Show the answer

It must be able to become competitive, and protection must be temporary.

Right. Otherwise protection just shields an inefficient industry for good.

Original teaching notes

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready