What this lesson teaches
I can weigh the benefits and costs of free trade and open flows for consumers, producers and governments.
Syllabus 9570, 3.3.1(c). Globalisation, International Trade and Economic Co-operation: Benefits and costs of free trade and flows of capital and labour on:; Consumers - Prices, choice and variety of goods and services; Producers - Size of markets, degree of competition, cost of production and innovation; Government - Macroeconomic objectives (and policy choice)
Make a guess
A tariff on imported fittings protects local fitting makers. What happens to a local furniture exporter that uses imported fittings?
- It gains, because protection helps local firms in the same industry chain.
- It is hurt, because its input costs rise.
- It is unaffected, because it sells its furniture abroad.
Show the answer
It is hurt, because its input costs rise.
Protection for one group of producers raises costs for firms that use the protected good as an input, making their exports less competitive.
Trade gives firms bigger markets and cheaper inputs, but exposes others to stronger competition.
Selling abroad lets firms sell far more than the home market allows, so they gain economies of scale. This matters greatly for Singapore, whose home market is small.
Imported inputs and machines can lower costs and raise quality.
But firms competing with imports face stronger competition. Some shrink or close, and their workers must move to other industries. Others cut costs and innovate to survive.
Many Singapore exports contain imported parts, so barriers on imports can raise exporters' costs.
- Gains
- Bigger markets, economies of scale, cheaper inputs.
- Costs
- Competition for import-competing firms.
Worked example: The China import shock, 1999 to 2011
As imports from China grew, US firms that competed with them cut jobs. Economists estimate that this cost about 2.0 to 2.4 million US jobs from 1999 to 2011. The losses were in factories and in the firms that supplied them (Acemoglu and others, 2016).
- US firms that competed with Chinese goods lost sales, shrank or closed.
- US firms that used cheap Chinese inputs gained lower costs.
- US consumers paid less for many goods.
- The losses were concentrated in certain towns, while the gains were spread thinly.
Watch out for this
Import competition can only harm local producers.
It can also push them to cut costs and innovate. The firms that survive often become more productive.
Check your understanding
Why does trade matter so much for Singapore's firms?
- Imported goods cost more than local ones, so firms must export to pay for them.
- Local buyers prefer foreign brands, so Singapore firms have to sell abroad.
- The domestic market is small, so exports let them reach economies of scale.
Show the answer
The domestic market is small, so exports let them reach economies of scale.
Right. Selling abroad lets them spread costs over much larger output.