Other forms of protection

H2 Economics - syllabus 9570, 2026

What this lesson teaches

  • I can weigh the benefits and costs of protectionism.

    Syllabus 9570, 3.3.1(d). Globalisation, International Trade and Economic Co-operation: Benefits and costs of protectionism

Make a guess

An import quota replaces a tariff, and licences are given free to importers. Who gets the money the tariff used to raise?

  1. The government, as with a tariff.
  2. Consumers, because the price falls.
  3. The importers who hold the licences.
Show the answer

The importers who hold the licences.

The domestic price still rises. With free licences, the gap between the domestic and world price goes to licence holders, not the government.

Quotas, subsidies to local producers and regulations also protect domestic industries, with different effects on who pays.

An import quota limits the quantity that can be imported. Like a tariff, it raises the domestic price. But instead of tariff revenue, the gap between the domestic and world price goes to whoever holds the import licences.

A production subsidy to domestic firms lowers their costs so they produce more. Consumers still pay the world price, but taxpayers fund the subsidy.

Other barriers include strict product standards, complex customs rules and export bans.

Each protects domestic producers, but at a cost to consumers, taxpayers or firms that use imported inputs.

Quota
Limits import quantity; licence holders gain.
Subsidy
Taxpayers fund it; consumers still pay the world price.

Worked example: A quota versus a subsidy

In the same market, an import quota of 40 units replaces the $1 tariff, with licences given free to importers. Alternatively, the government pays domestic producers a $1 subsidy per unit.

  1. Quota: the price rises to $5, as with the tariff. Importers keep the $40 that would have been tariff revenue.
  2. Subsidy: consumers still pay $4 and buy 120 units. Domestic firms produce 60, so 60 are imported.
  3. The subsidy costs taxpayers $1 x 60 = $60, but consumers do not lose.
  4. Each option protects producers; they differ in who pays.

Watch out for this

Every product standard is protection in disguise.

Not always. A safety or health standard can protect buyers. It works as protection only when it is stricter for imports than its purpose needs.

Check your understanding

A government pays local producers a subsidy instead of putting a tariff on imports. What happens to the price consumers pay?

  1. It falls below the world price, because local firms' costs fall.
  2. It stays at the world price, so consumers do not lose; taxpayers pay instead.
  3. It rises by the amount of the subsidy, as it would with a tariff.
Show the answer

It stays at the world price, so consumers do not lose; taxpayers pay instead.

Right. The subsidy lowers local firms' costs, so they produce more, but imports still come in at the world price. The cost falls on taxpayers.

Original teaching notes

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready