What this lesson teaches
I can define the key terms of an essay question and set a sensible scope for my answer.
Syllabus 8881, Paper 1 Content, Band 5. The terms and scope of the question are clearly understood and defined, with some subtlety.
I can root a 'your society' answer in Singapore's own traits, policies and debates.
Syllabus 8881, Additional marking guidance for Content. Answers to 'your society' or a specified society (Singapore) question need to be rooted in a specific society.
I can build a clear argument that rests on accurate evidence and my own reasoning.
Syllabus 8881, 3.1.4. formulate cogent, informed and insightful arguments
Make a guess
Question: 'How far is sport still a force for national unity?' Which closing sentence of an introduction would an examiner reward most?
- 'Sport has always been an important part of life in every society.'
- 'Sport still unites the nation in big moments, but rarely day to day.'
- 'This essay will look at the arguments for and against sport uniting the nation.'
Show the answer
'Sport still unites the nation in big moments, but rarely day to day.'
Right. It answers 'how far' with a degree and a condition, so the examiner knows what the essay will prove.
A GP introduction does three jobs: define the key terms, set the scope and state a clear, qualified stand.
The introduction is the first place an examiner sees whether you have read the question. It has three jobs: define the key terms, set the scope and state your stand. In a 500 to 800 word essay, keep it to one short paragraph.
Define the terms for this question, in your own words. A dictionary definition is too general to help. Say which meaning you will use and why it fits. For example, 'progress' could mean change that makes lives better, not change for its own sake.
Set the scope with the scope words you found. Say which people, places, times or forms the essay covers. In a 'your society' question, name Singapore and the traits that matter, such as an ageing population or an open economy.
State your stand in a sentence that answers the task words. 'How far' needs a degree, such as 'largely, but not when...'. A qualified stand gives the essay a direction, and the examiner knows what each paragraph will prove.
Sort these
Sort each sentence from an introduction by the job it does.
Groups: Defines a term, Sets the scope, States the stand, Does no work.
- Many people have different opinions about this question.
- Here, 'progress' means change that makes lives better, not change for its own sake.
- I will focus on news outlets in Singapore and the platforms that carry their stories.
- I will argue that tradition slows progress only when it shuts groups out.
- I will argue that exams measure some talents well, but not creativity or character.
- This essay looks at young people in Singapore, compared with their parents' generation.
- Here, 'national unity' means a shared sense of belonging across race and religion.
- In today's fast-changing world, this is a very important issue.
Show the answer
Defines a term
- Here, 'progress' means change that makes lives better, not change for its own sake. It says which meaning of the concept the essay will use, so it defines a key term.
- Here, 'national unity' means a shared sense of belonging across race and religion. It says which meaning of a key concept the essay will use, so it defines a term.
Sets the scope
- I will focus on news outlets in Singapore and the platforms that carry their stories. It limits which media the essay discusses. That sets the scope rather than taking a side.
- This essay looks at young people in Singapore, compared with their parents' generation. It fixes the group, the place and the time the essay covers, so it sets the scope.
States the stand
- I will argue that tradition slows progress only when it shuts groups out. It answers the question with a condition, so it is the stand the essay will prove.
- I will argue that exams measure some talents well, but not creativity or character. It takes a side with a limit attached, so it states a qualified stand.
Does no work
- Many people have different opinions about this question. It could be said of any question. It names no view, so it defines, limits and argues nothing.
- In today's fast-changing world, this is a very important issue. It could open any essay. It defines nothing, limits nothing and argues nothing.
Cut sentences that do no work. A general hook about 'today's fast-changing world', a list of the points to come, or 'This essay will discuss both sides' could open any essay. Every sentence should define, limit or argue.
- Introduction
- Define the key terms, set the scope, state your stand.
- Stand
- Answer the task words with a degree and a condition.
- Cut
- Generic hooks, lists of points and 'this essay will discuss'.
Model introductions for the eight questions (written by Wise Otter)
'Young people today care more about image than substance.' Discuss.
Young people today grow up on platforms that reward how things look: a well-lit photo, a follower count, a polished profile. Image is how a person appears to others; substance is what they can actually do or believe. Critics say the first has crowded out the second. I will argue that young people care about image more visibly than earlier generations, but not more than substance, because the two now often work together: an online portfolio is image built on real work.
To what extent should the arts in your society rely on public funding?
In Singapore, the state pays for much of the arts through grants, subsidised spaces and commissions, from community theatre to the Esplanade. To 'rely' on public funding is to depend on it to survive. I will argue that the arts here should rely on it for what the market will not pay for, such as new local work and access for people who cannot afford tickets. They should not depend on it entirely, because a single funder can make artists cautious and narrow the range of voices.
Is technology making us less patient?
Food arrives within the hour, videos play one after another, and messages show when they have been read. Patience, the willingness to wait or to keep at something hard, seems to be shrinking. I will argue that some technologies, especially apps built to hold attention, do make many people less patient with slow tasks. But 'technology' is too broad a culprit. The same tools also help people persist at long goals, from learning a language to sticking to a training plan.
'Tradition is a barrier to progress.' How far do you agree?
Tradition means practices and beliefs handed down, from festival customs to the way a family runs its business. Progress is harder to define; here it means change that makes lives better, not change for its own sake. To call tradition 'a barrier' is a strong claim. I will argue that some traditions do slow progress, especially those that shut groups out, but that many others help progress by giving people the trust and identity they need to accept change.
Should a small state always side with the powerful?
A small state such as Singapore has little military or economic weight of its own, so the pull to side with powerful countries is strong. 'Siding' can mean a formal alliance or simply quiet agreement. The word to test is 'always'. I will argue that a small state should work closely with powerful countries where its interests match theirs. Always siding with them, though, would make it a follower, and its long-term safety rests on international rules that protect the weak.
How far is sport still a force for national unity?
Sport has long brought nations together, in stadiums and around shared screens. 'Still' asks whether that holds now that top sport is global, commercial and often watched alone on a phone. National unity means a shared sense of belonging across class, race and religion. I will argue that sport still unites a nation in rare, big moments, as when Joseph Schooling won Singapore's first Olympic gold medal in 2016. Day to day, however, it divides fans by club and platform more than it binds them as citizens.
'The news media should give people what they want.' Discuss.
News outlets can now see, minute by minute, which stories people click. The temptation is to give readers more of what they want: scandal, celebrity and outrage. But what people want and what a society needs to know may differ. I will argue that the news media should take readers' wishes seriously in how they tell stories, but not in deciding which stories matter. News serves the public as citizens, not only as customers.
Is it ever right to break the law?
Laws are a society's rules, backed by punishment, but what is legal and what is right are not always the same. 'Ever' sets a low bar: one clear case of a justified breach is enough to answer yes. The harder questions are which laws, by what means, and at what cost. I will argue that breaking the law can be right in rare cases, when a law is gravely unjust and lawful ways of changing it have failed, but that in a working democracy such cases are very few.
Worked example: Building one introduction
Question: 'Technology always brings people closer together.' How far do you agree?
- Define: 'closer together' means deeper ties, not just more contact.
- Scope: people of different ages, in Singapore and beyond.
- Stand: technology increases contact, but brings people closer only when it supports time together.
- Draft: 'Messaging apps and video calls have made contact constant and cheap. Yet being closer means deeper ties, not just more messages. Looking across ages and countries, I will argue that technology brings people closer only when it supports, rather than replaces, time spent together.'
Watch out for this
A strong introduction opens with a dramatic hook and a dictionary definition.
Examiners reward definitions that fit the question and a clear stand. A generic hook or a dictionary definition fills space without showing that you have read the question.
Check your understanding
Which opening best roots a 'your society' essay in Singapore?
- Like many societies around the world, Singapore faces this issue in some way
- Singapore, a little red dot, has come a long way since 1965
- As a small, ageing city-state, Singapore faces this issue sharply
Show the answer
As a small, ageing city-state, Singapore faces this issue sharply
Right. It names traits that matter to the issue, so the argument that follows can depend on them.