What this lesson teaches
I can use a range of precise examples and explain how each one proves my point.
Syllabus 8881, Paper 1 Content, Band 5. Fully appropriate and wide-ranging illustration is used and developed throughout to support the points made within the argument.
I can build a clear argument that rests on accurate evidence and my own reasoning.
Syllabus 8881, 3.1.4. formulate cogent, informed and insightful arguments
Make a guess
A paragraph argues that sport can unite a nation. Which example would an examiner credit most?
- Many people in Singapore enjoy watching football
- Joseph Schooling's Olympic gold for Singapore in 2016
- Famous athletes such as Messi, Federer and Serena Williams
Show the answer
Joseph Schooling's Olympic gold for Singapore in 2016
Right. It is specific and dated, so it can be checked, and you can explain why it brought people together.
Choose examples from different countries, fields and periods, then develop each one: what happened, why it proves your point, and how far it holds.
Examples are the evidence for your argument. The top band wants 'wide-ranging illustration', developed throughout. Draw examples from different countries, fields and periods. Then develop each one: say what happened, why it proves your point, and how far it can be generalised.
A strong example is specific. It says who, where and when, and gives a figure if one helps. 'In 2016, Joseph Schooling won Singapore's first Olympic gold medal' can be checked. 'A Singaporean once did well at sport' cannot.
Beware stock context. Opening with 'Singapore, a small red dot' or a list of famous names adds nothing unless the context explains your point. This is often called name-dropping. Every fact you bring in should do work in the argument.
Sort these
Is each example developed, or only named or stock context?
Groups: Developed, Only named or stock.
- In 2016, Joseph Schooling won Singapore's first Olympic gold medal, and crowds lined the streets for his victory parade.
- Many countries have had problems with fake news in recent years.
- Leaders such as Gandhi, Mandela and Lee Kuan Yew show the power of ideas.
- Singapore, a little red dot, has come a long way since 1965.
- Bhutan measures progress with Gross National Happiness, which counts wellbeing as well as income.
- From 2021, PSLE scores moved from T-scores to wider Achievement Level bands, to avoid overly fine differences in results.
Show the answer
Developed
- In 2016, Joseph Schooling won Singapore's first Olympic gold medal, and crowds lined the streets for his victory parade. It is specific and dated, and it says why the moment mattered for unity.
- Bhutan measures progress with Gross National Happiness, which counts wellbeing as well as income. It names a country, a measure and what the measure adds, so it can test how progress is defined.
- From 2021, PSLE scores moved from T-scores to wider Achievement Level bands, to avoid overly fine differences in results. It states the change, its date and its purpose, so it can support a point about competition.
Only named or stock
- Many countries have had problems with fake news in recent years. It names no country, date or case, so an examiner cannot credit it as evidence.
- Leaders such as Gandhi, Mandela and Lee Kuan Yew show the power of ideas. It lists famous names without saying what any of them did, so it is name-dropping.
- Singapore, a little red dot, has come a long way since 1965. This is stock context. It fits any essay and proves nothing about the question.
Keep a small bank of flexible examples, each with its date and source. Facts change, so check the latest details before an exam. One example can serve several topics if you explain the link each time.
- Developing an example
- What happened, why it proves the point, how far it generalises.
- Wide-ranging
- Examples from different countries, fields and periods.
- Stock context
- Background that explains nothing, such as 'a little red dot'.
Worked example: Developing one example
Point: sport can still unite a nation. Example: Joseph Schooling's Olympic gold.
- What happened: in August 2016, Joseph Schooling won the 100 m butterfly at the Rio Olympics, beating Michael Phelps. It was Singapore's first Olympic gold medal.
- Why it proves the point: people of every background shared the win, and crowds lined the streets for his victory parade.
- How far it holds: such moments are rare. Day to day, many fans follow foreign clubs on their own phones.
- Judgement: sport unites people in big national moments more than in daily life.
Watch out for this
The more examples I list, the better my essay.
A list of names is name-dropping. One example that is explained and tested earns more than five that are only mentioned.
Check your understanding
You have used one Singapore example for a point. What would make the illustration wider-ranging?
- Name several famous people who are linked to the issue
- Add two more facts and figures that show the same Singapore example in detail
- Add a case from another country or field and compare it
Show the answer
Add a case from another country or field and compare it
Right. A second context shows the idea holds, or changes, beyond one case, which is what 'wide-ranging' means.