What this lesson teaches
I can end an essay with a measured judgement that states when my view holds.
Syllabus 8881, Paper 1 Content, Band 5. The conclusion is measured and nuanced.
I can build a clear argument that rests on accurate evidence and my own reasoning.
Syllabus 8881, 3.1.4. formulate cogent, informed and insightful arguments
Make a guess
Should a conclusion bring in a new example so that the essay ends strongly?
- No. It should judge using points already made.
- Yes, as long as it supports your stand.
- Yes. A new example makes the ending memorable.
Show the answer
No. It should judge using points already made.
Right. A new example opens an argument you have no space to develop. The conclusion weighs what the essay has shown.
A measured conclusion answers the question with conditions: how far your stand holds, for whom and when.
The top content band asks for a conclusion that is 'measured and nuanced' in its judgement. A Band 3 conclusion is 'likely to be assertive or a summary of the argument' instead. So the last paragraph can lift or sink the whole essay.
A measured conclusion answers the question with conditions. It says how far, for whom, and under what circumstances your stand holds. It draws your criteria together without listing every paragraph again.
Avoid two weak endings. Fence-sitting says 'both sides have their merits' or 'it depends' without naming on what. Overclaiming says 'must' or 'always' and ignores the limits the essay has weighed.
Sort these
Is each closing sentence measured, fence-sitting or overclaiming?
Groups: Measured, Fence-sitting, Overclaiming.
- Both sides have valid points, so it is hard to say.
- Tradition must always give way to progress, whatever the cost.
- Clearly, technology has ruined every young person's ability to focus.
- Whether it is good or bad depends on many factors.
- Remote work suits many office jobs, though less so for new staff who learn by watching others.
- Choice helps most when people have the information and time to use it, and less when they do not.
Show the answer
Measured
- Remote work suits many office jobs, though less so for new staff who learn by watching others. It names where the claim holds and for whom it does not, so the judgement is measured.
- Choice helps most when people have the information and time to use it, and less when they do not. It answers with a condition, so the reader knows when the stand holds.
Fence-sitting
- Both sides have valid points, so it is hard to say. It refuses to judge. A conclusion must answer how far, even if the answer is qualified.
- Whether it is good or bad depends on many factors. It says 'depends' but never names the factors, so nothing is judged.
Overclaiming
- Tradition must always give way to progress, whatever the cost. 'Always' and 'whatever the cost' state a rule with no conditions, so it is not measured.
- Clearly, technology has ruined every young person's ability to focus. 'Ruined' and 'every' ignore the exceptions the essay should have weighed.
Add no new example or argument. A fresh case in the last paragraph is left unexplained and untested. Instead, end on the wider implication: why the answer matters for people or for society.
- Measured conclusion
- How far, for whom, and under what conditions.
- No new example
- Judge using the points the essay has already made.
- Avoid
- Fence-sitting and overclaiming.
Worked example: From fence-sitting to measured
Question: 'Is technology making us less patient?'
- Fence-sitting: 'There are arguments on both sides, so it depends.'
- Name the condition: which technology, and for whom? Apps built to hold attention, for heavy users.
- Say how far: 'largely', not 'always'.
- Measured: apps built to hold attention are making many heavy users less patient with slow tasks. The same tools help others persist, so the habit, more than the device, decides the effect.
Watch out for this
A good conclusion sums up both sides equally and ends with 'it depends'.
A measured conclusion still answers the question. Say how far your stand holds, for whom and under what conditions, and name what it depends on.
Check your understanding
Which conclusion is most measured?
- In conclusion, the government must protect our national heritage at any cost, because it shapes who we are
- In conclusion, the state should lead where heritage needs land and law, but living practices depend on communities
- In conclusion, both sides have their merits, so the answer depends on many different factors
Show the answer
In conclusion, the state should lead where heritage needs land and law, but living practices depend on communities
Right. It answers how far, with conditions about which heritage and whose role.