Evaluating market failure policies

H1 Economics - syllabus 8843, 2026

What this lesson teaches

  • I can explain equity as a fair share of essential goods and services.

    Syllabus 8843, 2.2.1(e). Governments' Microeconomic Objectives: Equity occurs when there is fairness in the distribution of essential goods and services

  • I can explain why a government steps in to improve efficiency and equity.

    Syllabus 8843, 2.2.3(a). Microeconomic Policies: Microeconomic policy decisions undertaken by governments to achieve microeconomic objectives in relation to efficiency and equity

  • I can judge how well each policy achieves efficiency and equity.

    Syllabus 8843, 2.2.3(c). Microeconomic Policies: Effectiveness of policy measures in achieving efficiency and equity

Make a guess

A higher petrol tax is meant to cut pollution. Which households pay the largest share of their income in this tax?

  1. High-income households, because they drive bigger cars.
  2. Lower-income households who must drive.
  3. Every household pays the same share.
Show the answer

Lower-income households who must drive.

Fuel takes a bigger share of a low-income household's spending, so the tax takes a bigger share of its income. Who pays is part of judging a policy.

Judge a policy by whether it fixes the cause, what it costs and who is affected, compared with the alternatives.

Start with the cause of the failure, then check whether the policy targets it.

Consider the size of the effect. A tax on a good with inelastic demand cuts consumption only a little. Education takes time to work.

Consider the costs: the tax revenue or spending, enforcement, and the risk of setting the policy at the wrong level.

Consider who gains and loses. A tax on fuel falls hardest on lower-income households. A combination of policies often works better than any one, and Singapore commonly uses a mix of price measures and rules.

Ask
Does it target the cause? At what cost? Who gains and loses?
Often best
A mix of policies.

Worked example: London's congestion charge

On 17 February 2003, London began charging drivers 5 pounds a day to enter its centre. In the first year, traffic entering the zone fell by about 18%.

  1. Cause: drivers ignore the delay they cause others. The charge targets this directly.
  2. Size: by 2008, traffic was still about 21% lower, but congestion was back to its level before the charge.
  3. Why: roadworks, and road space given to buses, cyclists and pedestrians, left less room for cars.
  4. Judge over time: a policy that works at first may need adjusting later.

Watch out for this

To discuss a policy, I start by explaining how the policy works.

Start with the market failure: name its source and show Qp against Qs. Then judge whether the policy closes that gap. Without the cause, the analysis has nothing to aim at.

Check your understanding

Demand for petrol is very price inelastic. What does this mean for a petrol tax meant to reduce pollution?

  1. It will cut consumption sharply.
  2. It will have no effect at all.
  3. It will raise revenue but cut consumption only a little.
Show the answer

It will raise revenue but cut consumption only a little.

Right. Inelastic demand means small quantity responses.

Original teaching notes

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready