Public goods

H1 Economics - syllabus 8843, 2026

What this lesson teaches

  • I can explain the causes of market failure: public goods, externalities and information failure.

    Syllabus 8843, 2.2.2(b). Market Failure and its Causes: Markets may fail in terms of; non-provision of public goods due to non-rivalry and non- excludability; non-socially optimal levels of goods and services due to the presence of externalities and/or information failure

Make a guess

Why do private firms not build flood barriers to sell protection to homeowners?

  1. People protected by the barrier cannot be made to pay.
  2. Flood barriers are too expensive for any firm to build.
  3. The government bans private firms from building them.
Show the answer

People protected by the barrier cannot be made to pay.

A flood barrier is non-excludable. Everyone behind it is safe whether they pay or not, so many would free-ride and the firm could not cover its costs.

Public goods are non-excludable and non-rival, so the free market provides too little or none at all.

A pure public good has two features. It is non-excludable: once it is provided, no one can be stopped from benefiting. It is non-rival: one more user does not reduce what others get, so serving one more user costs nothing.

Many public goods are also non-rejectable: people cannot refuse the benefit once it is there. Do not mix this up with non-excludable. That is about stopping people who have not paid.

Because people benefit whether or not they pay, each has a reason to let others pay. This is the free-rider problem. Firms cannot earn enough revenue, so the market supplies none of the good: a missing market.

Examples in Singapore include national defence, street lighting and flood control such as the Marina Barrage. The government provides them and pays from taxes.

Many goods are only partly public. These quasi-public goods are non-rival until they get crowded, and costly but possible to charge for. A road is non-rival when empty but rival in a jam. Singapore charges drivers on busy roads, so exclusion is possible.

So a market may supply some quasi-public goods, such as toll roads or ticketed parks. It usually supplies too little. Governments often provide them, and may charge only when crowding makes use rival.

Public good
Non-excludable and non-rival; often non-rejectable too.
Result
Free riding; missing market.
Quasi-public good
Partly non-rival and partly non-excludable, such as a road: rival when congested, and drivers can be charged.
Classify by characteristics, not by who provides it
GoodExcludable?Rival?Type
National defenceNoNoPublic good
Street lightingNoNoPublic good
HealthcareYesYesMerit good
EducationYesYesMerit good

Worked example: Singapore's warning sirens

Every 15 February and 15 September, Singapore's civil defence force sounds its warning sirens across the island. In an emergency, the same sirens tell people to tune in to the radio.

  1. Non-excludable: everyone in range hears the warning, whether or not they pay tax.
  2. Non-rival: one more listener does not make the siren quieter for anyone else.
  3. Non-rejectable: people near a siren cannot choose not to hear it.
  4. No firm could sell this service, so the government provides it and pays from taxes.

Watch out for this

Anything the government provides is a public good.

Public goods are defined by their features, not by who provides them. Education and healthcare are excludable and rival. So they are not public goods, even when the state provides them.

Check your understanding

Why won't private firms supply street lighting?

  1. People can benefit without paying, so firms cannot collect enough revenue to cover costs.
  2. Street lighting costs too much to build for any firm to make a profit.
  3. Few people value street lighting, so demand is too low for a firm to cover the cost.
Show the answer

People can benefit without paying, so firms cannot collect enough revenue to cover costs.

Right. Non-excludability creates the free-rider problem.

Original teaching notes

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready