Negative externalities

H1 Economics - syllabus 8843, 2026

What this lesson teaches

  • I can explain that a market is efficient at the social optimum, where marginal social benefit equals marginal social cost.

    Syllabus 8843, 2.2.1(b). Governments' Microeconomic Objectives: Efficiency in markets occurs when the social optimum is achieved, where Marginal Social Benefit (MSB) = Marginal Social Cost (MSC), maximising society's welfare

  • I can explain the causes of market failure: public goods, externalities and information failure.

    Syllabus 8843, 2.2.2(b). Market Failure and its Causes: Markets may fail in terms of; non-provision of public goods due to non-rivalry and non- excludability; non-socially optimal levels of goods and services due to the presence of externalities and/or information failure

Make a guess

Drivers on a busy road at 6pm pay for their own petrol and time. Without road charges, how much driving happens at peak hour?

  1. Too much, because drivers ignore the delay they cause others.
  2. The right amount, because drivers pay all their own costs.
  3. Too little, because traffic jams put many people off driving at that hour.
Show the answer

Too much, because drivers ignore the delay they cause others.

Each driver adds to the jam for everyone else but does not pay for it. The free market output is above the efficient level.

When an activity harms third parties, the free market produces too much of it.

A negative externality is a cost imposed on third parties, people outside the transaction, that nobody pays for. Car exhaust, traffic congestion and noise are examples.

Producers and consumers consider only their private costs (MPC). The true cost to society, the marginal social cost (MSC), is MPC plus the marginal external cost (MEC).

The free market produces where MPB = MPC, at Qp. The efficient output is where MSB = MSC, at Qs. Since MSC is above MPC, Qp is greater than Qs: the good is overproduced.

For each unit between Qs and Qp, the cost to society is more than the benefit. The total of these losses is the deadweight loss.

MSC
MPC + MEC.
Result
Qp > Qs: overproduction.
Name the third party
Say who bears the cost and why the decision maker ignores it.

Worked example: Second-hand smoke on Orchard Road

Smoke from a cigarette drifts onto people nearby. Since 1 January 2019, smoking in the public areas of Orchard Road has been allowed only in marked smoking areas.

  1. A smoker weighs his own benefit against his own costs: the price and the harm to his health.
  2. Passers-by breathe the smoke but have no say in his choice. Their harm is an external cost.
  3. He ignores that cost, so MSC is above MPC, and there is more smoking on busy streets than is efficient.
  4. The rule moves smoking away from crowds. Smokers caught outside the marked areas can be fined.

Watch out for this

Smoking has a negative externality because it damages the smoker's lungs.

That harm falls on the smoker, so it is a private cost. The externality is the harm to third parties, such as people who breathe the smoke. Always name who they are.

Check your understanding

A factory pollutes a river. Without intervention, how does its output compare with the efficient level?

  1. It produces the efficient amount, because it maximises profit.
  2. It produces too much, because it ignores the cost of the pollution to people downstream.
  3. It produces too little, because the cost of pollution makes it cut back.
Show the answer

It produces too much, because it ignores the cost of the pollution to people downstream.

Right. Qp is greater than Qs when there is a negative externality.

Original teaching notes

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready