Direct and joint provision

H1 Economics - syllabus 8843, 2026

What this lesson teaches

  • I can explain how taxes, subsidies, quotas, tradeable permits, provision, rules and public education correct market failure.

    Syllabus 8843, 2.2.3(b). Microeconomic Policies: Policy measures including taxes and subsidies, quotas and tradeable permits, joint and direct provision, rules and regulations, public education in achieving efficiency and equity

Make a guess

The government pays for 200 extra clinic appointments a month. Must it run the clinics itself?

  1. No. It can fund a private provider to deliver them.
  2. Yes. Government money must go to government clinics.
  3. Yes, because private firms cannot be trusted with public money.
Show the answer

No. It can fund a private provider to deliver them.

Funding and delivery are separate. A government can pay a private firm to provide a service.

The government can provide goods itself, or share provision with the private sector.

Public goods are usually provided directly by the government and paid for from taxes, because the market would not supply them.

Merit goods are often jointly provided. In joint provision, the government supplies part of the good itself, alongside private firms, so total supply rises.

This is not the same as a subsidy. With a subsidy, the government pays private firms, but the firms still decide how much to supply and how to deliver it.

Direct provision uses tax money, which has an opportunity cost. It is also hard to judge how much to supply. Without competition, public providers may become less efficient.

Public goods
Provided by government, funded by taxes.
Joint provision
Government supplies part of a merit good alongside private firms.

Worked example: Primary care in Singapore

Government polyclinics work alongside private GP clinics. In May 2026, the health minister said polyclinics have about 10% of primary care doctors but handle close to half the chronic workload.

  1. Private GPs, most of the primary care doctors, see most coughs, colds and fevers.
  2. Polyclinics add supply where the market alone may give too little: subsidised care for long-term illness.
  3. Together they raise total supply. That is joint provision.
  4. Judge it by access and cost, such as waiting times and the tax money each visit uses.

Watch out for this

Joint provision means the government gives private clinics a subsidy, so I shift the MPB curve right.

That describes a subsidy. In joint provision the government supplies part of the good itself, so market supply rises. Show more supply, not a shift in MPB.

Check your understanding

Why does the government directly provide national defence?

  1. It is a public good, so the market would not provide it.
  2. Defence has negative externalities, so the market would make too much.
  3. Private firms would charge too much for it.
Show the answer

It is a public good, so the market would not provide it.

Right. Free riding means no private firm could collect enough revenue.

Original teaching notes

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready