What this lesson teaches
I can judge how colonial rule changed politics, the economy and society in Southeast Asia after 1870, and who gained or lost.
Syllabus K330, Extension of European Control in Southeast Asia, Learning Outcomes. Evaluate the impact of European influence on Southeast Asia after 1870.
Make a guess
Vietnamese opponents of French rule all wanted to end it. Do you think they agreed on how to do it?
- No, some chose armed revolt, others help from abroad or reform.
- Yes, they joined together in armed revolt from 1885 onwards.
- No, because they disagreed about whether French rule should end.
Show the answer
No, some chose armed revolt, others help from abroad or reform.
Can Vuong fought for the emperor, Phan Boi Chau sought support in Japan, and Phan Chau Trinh pressed for education and reform.
Vietnamese opponents of French rule agreed on the goal but chose different methods: armed revolt, help from abroad, or reform.
Can Vuong means Aid the King. In 1885 Emperor Ham Nghi called for armed resistance against France. This gave fighters a leader and a cause to rally around. But French forces captured Ham Nghi in 1888 and sent him into exile in Algeria. By 1896 the movement had been crushed. So later activists tried other routes instead of repeating the same strategy.
Phan Boi Chau looked for support abroad, including in Japan. He wanted to train followers and gather resources to fight French rule. Phan Chau Trinh focused on schools, skills and reform. He believed a better educated people could claim their rights. Both valued education, but they had different priorities.
The French watched activists closely and punished them. Working with the French on one issue did not mean accepting French rule forever. And not all opponents chose to fight. To explain a response, link what people wanted to the method they chose.
- Can Vuong, 1885
- Armed resistance in support of Emperor Ham Nghi.
- Phan Boi Chau
- Sought help abroad, including Japan.
- Phan Chau Trinh
- Pushed for schools and reform.
Real examples to use
Go East movement, from 1905
Phan Boi Chau sent young Vietnamese to study in Japan, about 200 of them by 1908. Under pressure from France, Japan expelled him in 1909.
Tonkin Free School, 1907
Phan Chau Trinh helped open this school in Hanoi to teach modern ideas. The French closed it in late 1907. After tax revolts in 1908, they arrested him.
Worked example: Compare the two Phan leaders
Phan Boi Chau later described their difference. 'He wished to start by relying on the French to abolish the monarchy, but I wished to start by driving out the French'.
- Phan Boi Chau: drive out the French first, with training and help from abroad.
- Phan Chau Trinh: work through the French for schools and reform, and end the monarchy.
- Same wish for change, different first steps. Link each method to what the leader wanted.
Watch out for this
Only armed resistance counts as a response to French rule.
Education, reform and building support abroad were also ways to resist.
Check your understanding
What was Phan Chau Trinh's main approach?
- Seeking help from Japan to train Vietnamese fighters abroad.
- Schools, skills and reform to help Vietnamese claim their rights.
- Armed revolt to restore Emperor Ham Nghi to power.
Show the answer
Schools, skills and reform to help Vietnamese claim their rights.
Yes. He focused on education and reform at home.
Check your understanding
Why did later activists such as Phan Boi Chau try new methods instead of another Can Vuong revolt?
- France had crushed Can Vuong, so they looked for other ways to build strength.
- The French had invited them to share power, so revolt was unnecessary.
- Can Vuong had already won independence, so no more fighting was needed.
Show the answer
France had crushed Can Vuong, so they looked for other ways to build strength.
Yes. Ham Nghi was captured in 1888 and the revolt was crushed by 1896, so later leaders tried help from abroad and reform.