New jobs and schools, but unequal rights

G3 Full History - syllabus K330, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how colonial rule changed politics, the economy and society in Southeast Asia after 1870, and who gained or lost.

    Syllabus K330, Extension of European Control in Southeast Asia, Learning Outcomes. Evaluate the impact of European influence on Southeast Asia after 1870.

Make a guess

A small group of Vietnamese went to French-language schools. Do you think they all supported French rule?

  1. No, because the schools taught in Vietnamese and banned French ideas.
  2. Yes, French schooling turned them into loyal supporters of French rule.
  3. No, some used their learning to criticise and organise against it.
Show the answer

No, some used their learning to criticise and organise against it.

Education opened jobs and new ideas. Some took posts in the system; others used those ideas against unfair rule.

Some Vietnamese gained jobs or a French education, but many were landless, and all had fewer rights than the French.

Mines, plantations and towns drew workers from across Indochina. A plantation is a large farm growing crops for sale. Moving for work could bring wages. But it also cut people off from their villages. Landless peasants had to rent land or find paid work. So people's chances depended on their land, skills and access to jobs, not simply on whether the economy grew.

A small group went to French-language schools. They became a Western-educated elite. Their education opened doors to good jobs and new ideas. Some used their learning to criticise unfair treatment and to organise.

Going to a French school did not mean agreeing with French rule. And most Vietnamese could not go to these schools. Education did not give Vietnamese people equal power with French officials.

Plantation
Large farm growing crops for sale.
Western-educated elite
Small group schooled in French.
Limit
Most people had no access to these schools.

Real examples to use

Quoc Hoc school, Hue, 1896

This school was set up to train students to serve the government, with French as the main subject. Nguyen Tat Thanh, later known as Ho Chi Minh, was admitted in 1908.

Worked example: Phu Rieng rubber estate, late 1920s

Phu Rieng, in the south, was Michelin's biggest rubber estate in Vietnam. It hired workers from crowded Tonkin, in the north, on contracts of several years. In one year in the late 1920s, about 17 per cent of its workers died.

  1. Gain: landless families from Tonkin could earn a wage.
  2. Cost: workers were far from home, tied to contracts and exposed to disease.
  3. So a new job did not always mean a better life. Ask who carried the risks.

Watch out for this

People who gained from French education must have supported French rule.

Many educated Vietnamese used what they learnt to question and oppose colonial rule.

Check your understanding

How could French education help Vietnamese opposition?

  1. It gave some people ideas and skills to criticise unequal treatment.
  2. It made educated people loyal to France and proud of French culture.
  3. It gave educated Vietnamese equal rights with French citizens.
Show the answer

It gave some people ideas and skills to criticise unequal treatment.

Yes. Education could be used to question French rule.

Check your understanding

Why might a landless peasant in Tonkin sign a contract to work on a rubber estate in the south, despite the dangers?

  1. Without land, paid work was one of the few ways to earn a living.
  2. The contracts let workers leave whenever they wished, so there was little risk.
  3. The estates promised each worker a farm of his own after one harvest.
Show the answer

Without land, paid work was one of the few ways to earn a living.

Yes. Landless people had to rent land or find wages, so even risky contracts far from home could attract them.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready