Rice, coal and who kept the money

G3 Full History - syllabus K330, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how colonial rule changed politics, the economy and society in Southeast Asia after 1870, and who gained or lost.

    Syllabus K330, Extension of European Control in Southeast Asia, Learning Outcomes. Evaluate the impact of European influence on Southeast Asia after 1870.

Make a guess

Rice and coal exports from French Vietnam grew fast. Who do you think kept most of the money?

  1. Ordinary farmers, who sold their rice abroad at high prices.
  2. Mine workers, who were paid a share of coal profits.
  3. Big landowners, investors and the colonial state.
Show the answer

Big landowners, investors and the colonial state.

Many peasants lost land and paid rent, taxes and debts, while state monopolies on salt and alcohol raised money from families.

Rice and coal exports grew, but rent, taxes, debt and French monopolies left many ordinary people with little.

Rice farming in the south and coal mining in the north grew fast. Much of it was sold overseas. Roads, railways and ports helped move goods. Some people found new jobs. But the French and investors set the rules for land, work and trade.

Big landowners gained land. Many peasants, or small farmers, lost land and became tenants. A tenant farms someone else's land and pays rent. Farmers also paid taxes to the government and repaid debts to lenders.

The colonial government also had monopolies, the only legal right to sell salt, alcohol and opium. This raised money for the state, but made families pay more. So higher sales did not mean ordinary people got richer.

Exports
Rice from the south, coal from the north.
Tenant
Farms someone else's land and pays rent.
Monopolies
French control of salt, alcohol and opium sales.

Real examples to use

Paul Doumer, 1897 to 1902

As governor-general, he raised taxes on opium, alcohol and salt to make the colony pay for itself. People who could not pay their taxes could lose their houses and land.

Worked example: Cochinchina's rice land, 1930

Rice exports from the south grew fast. Yet by 1930, a quarter of landowners owned 80 per cent of the rice land. And 57 per cent of country people had no land and worked on large estates.

  1. Much of the rice was grown by tenants and labourers, not by the owners of the land.
  2. Tenants paid rent from each harvest, and many owed money to lenders.
  3. So export growth mostly rewarded landowners and traders, not the families who farmed.

Watch out for this

An export economy made most people rich.

Exports grew, but rent, taxes, debt and monopoly prices took much of what farmers earned.

Check your understanding

Why could a tenant farmer stay poor even when rice sales grew?

  1. Tenants owned their land, so they paid no rent.
  2. The French banned rice exports.
  3. Rent, taxes and debt took much of the income.
Show the answer

Rent, taxes and debt took much of the income.

Yes. Selling more did not mean keeping more.

Check your understanding

From 1897 Governor-General Paul Doumer raised taxes on salt, alcohol and opium. Why could this leave families worse off even as exports grew?

  1. Families paid more for goods they needed, and the state kept the money.
  2. The tax money was spent on raising the wages of rice farmers.
  3. Only French companies paid these taxes, so ordinary families lost nothing.
Show the answer

Families paid more for goods they needed, and the state kept the money.

Yes. Taxes and monopoly prices took money from households to pay for the colony.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready