Lesson 12 of 12
Fixed charge, fixed p.d. and charging losses
I can use the area under a graph of p.d. against charge, and U = QV/2 = Q^2/(2C) = CV^2/2, for stored energy.Syllabus
Syllabus 9478, 14(k). Use the area under a graph of p.d. against charge, and U = QV/2 = Q^2/(2C) = CV^2/2, for stored energy.
Before comparing stored energies, decide what stays fixed. At a fixed p.d., U = (1/2)CV2 rises with C. At a fixed charge, U = Q2/(2C) falls as C rises.
The same capacitor at a higher p.d.
For one capacitor, C is fixed. Doubling V doubles Q, so U = (1/2)QV goes up four times. The 10.0 microfarad capacitor at 24.0 V holds 240 microcoulombs and stores 2.88 mJ.
Different capacitors: what is held fixed?
A capacitor left connected to a battery keeps the battery's p.d., so V is fixed. A charged capacitor that is disconnected keeps its charge, if none leaks away, so Q is fixed.
| Case | Charge and p.d. | U / mJ |
|---|---|---|
| Start: C = 10.0 microfarad | Q = 120 microcoulomb V = 12.0 V | 0.720 |
| C = 20.0 microfarad, same Q | Q = 120 microcoulomb V = 6.0 V | 0.360 |
| C = 20.0 microfarad, same V | Q = 240 microcoulomb V = 12.0 V | 1.44 |
These are two separate comparisons. You cannot hold both Q and V fixed while C changes.
Check your understanding
A 10.0 microfarad capacitor at 12.0 V stores 0.720 mJ and has plate-charge magnitude 120 microcoulomb. Compare a 20.0 microfarad capacitor, first at the same charge and separately at the same voltage.
Show the answer
Its energy is 0.360 mJ at fixed charge and 1.44 mJ at fixed voltage.
At Q = 120 microcoulomb, U = Q2/(2C) halves. At V = 12.0 V, U = CV2/2 doubles. The two comparisons do not hold both Q and V fixed.
Energy from the battery
Charge an empty capacitor from a battery through a resistor. The battery pushes all the charge Q through its full p.d. V, so it supplies QV. The capacitor stores only (1/2)QV, because its own p.d. rose from zero. The other half becomes thermal energy in the resistor.
For the 10.0 microfarad capacitor charged to 12.0 V, the battery supplies 1.44 mJ. The capacitor stores 0.720 mJ, and 0.720 mJ heats the resistor.
Check your understanding
An uncharged 100 microfarad capacitor is charged through a resistor by a 6.0 V battery until it is full. How much energy does the battery supply, and how much does the capacitor store?
Show the answer
The battery supplies 3.6 mJ; the capacitor stores 1.8 mJ.
Q = CV = 600 microcoulomb. The battery moves all of it through 6.0 V, so it supplies QV = 3.6 mJ. The capacitor stores (1/2)QV = 1.8 mJ, and the other 1.8 mJ heats the resistor.
Say which quantity stays fixed before you compare energies. Using U = (1/2)CV2 when it is Q that stays fixed gives the wrong trend.