Lesson 10 of 10 / Practical and data skills
Indicators for carbon dioxide and for reduction
How can a colour change show respiration or photosynthesis happening?
I can use hydrogencarbonate indicator, methylene blue and DCPIP to follow gas exchange and reduction.
About 6 min
Make a guess. You are not marked.
Algal beads sit in red hydrogencarbonate indicator under a bright lamp. Which colour do you expect after an hour?
Show the answer
Purple, as carbon dioxide is taken up.
In bright light, photosynthesis uses more carbon dioxide than respiration releases, so the indicator becomes less acidic and turns purple.
The key idea
Hydrogencarbonate indicator shows whether carbon dioxide rises or falls, and methylene blue and DCPIP lose their blue colour when they are reduced.
Work with the evidence
Which way does the colour change?
More carbon dioxide: Hydrogencarbonate indicator changes from red to yellow.
Colours are approximate drawings. Methylene blue and DCPIP turn colourless when reduced; hydrogencarbonate indicator responds to carbon dioxide, not oxygen.
Explanation
An indicator is a chemical whose colour shows a condition. It lets you follow a process, such as respiration or photosynthesis, without measuring it directly.
Hydrogencarbonate indicator is red at the carbon dioxide level of normal air. More carbon dioxide makes it more acidic and turns it yellow; less carbon dioxide turns it purple. Respiring organisms release carbon dioxide. In bright light, photosynthesising organisms take up more than they release.
For example, algae trapped in beads of alginate jelly turn the indicator purple in bright light and yellow in the dark. Set up a control tube with indicator but no beads. A lamp also heats the tubes, so use a heat shield or a cold light source. Examiners did not credit a water bath, which would not work with that set-up.
Methylene blue changes from blue to colourless when it is reduced, which means it gains electrons or hydrogen. Respiring yeast reduces it, so the time it takes to lose its colour compares respiration rates, for example at different temperatures.
DCPIP also changes from blue to colourless when it is reduced. Vitamin C reduces it, so DCPIP can compare the vitamin C content of fruit juices. Chloroplasts isolated from leaves reduce it in light, showing the light-dependent reaction; in the dark it stays blue.
Record each result from the starting colour to the final colour, and time the change when comparing rates. Keep the volumes, the temperature and the amount of tissue the same.
Step by step
- 1
Name what the indicator detects
The carbon dioxide level, or reduction.
- 2
Predict the colour change
From the starting colour to the final colour.
- 3
Control the comparison
Same volumes, temperature and amount of tissue, and a control without organisms.
Worked example
Work through the evidence
Tubes of hydrogencarbonate indicator with algal beads are placed 10, 20 and 40 cm from a lamp for an hour. The nearest tube turns purple, the middle one stays red and the farthest turns yellow. Explain the colours.
One way to explain it
Near the lamp, photosynthesis is faster than respiration, so the algae take up carbon dioxide and the indicator turns purple. At 20 cm the two rates are about equal, so carbon dioxide does not change and it stays red. Far away, respiration is faster, so carbon dioxide rises and it turns yellow.
Why this answer works
- Light intensity falls with distance from the lamp.
- Red means no net change in carbon dioxide, not that photosynthesis has stopped.
Watch out for this
A student says: "Hydrogencarbonate indicator turns purple because the algae are making oxygen." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
It responds to carbon dioxide, not oxygen. It turns purple because net uptake of carbon dioxide makes the solution less acidic.
In the real world
Methylene blue in milk testing, 2024
The methylene blue reduction test can estimate the number of microbes in milk. Microbes reduce the blue dye to a colourless form, so the colour fades. In 2024 L. Roy and colleagues in Kolkata, India, built the test into a small device that measures the fall in the dye's light absorbance at 664 nm.
Check your understanding
Yeast in glucose solution decolourises methylene blue in 4 minutes at 30 degrees C and in 12 minutes at 20 degrees C. What does this show?
Show the answer
Respiration is faster at 30 degrees C, so the dye is reduced sooner.
A shorter time to lose the colour means faster reduction by the respiring yeast.
Quick recall
How can a colour change show respiration or photosynthesis happening?