Lesson 6 of 6
Controlling thermal transfer
I can apply conduction, convection and radiation to everyday situations and designs.Syllabus
Syllabus K326 / K327, 8(e). Apply conduction, convection and radiation to everyday situations and designs.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A vacuum flask keeps a drink hot. Which part mainly stops energy transfer by conduction and convection?
Show the answer
The vacuum between the walls, which has no particles to pass energy on.
Conduction and convection both need particles. A vacuum has almost none, so it blocks both. The silvered walls deal with radiation, and the cap with convection at the top.
To explain a thermal design, trace each transfer route. Then say which feature changes it.
Conduction transfers energy as particles act on their neighbours. Convection carries it with moving fluid. Radiation transfers it by electromagnetic waves. A temperature difference sets the direction of net heating. A real design can involve all three processes.
Why a vacuum flask has several features
James Dewar invented the vacuum flask in 1892. It has two walls with an evacuated space between them, reflective surfaces facing that gap, and a stopper at its opening. Each feature deals with a different route.
A flask reduces several routes of energy transfer
This schematic cutaway contains a warm drink in cooler surroundings. Match each numbered feature to its role below.
- Vacuum gap: reduces conduction and prevents convection across the gap.
- Reflective faces: reduce radiative transfer between the walls.
- Insulating stopper: reduces conduction and movement of fluid through the opening.
- Neck: the solid connection still conducts some energy.
- Small supports: hold the vessel in place but still provide conducting paths.
The same features also slow energy entering a cold drink from warmer surroundings.
- Evacuated gap
- Removing most gas particles greatly reduces conduction through the gap. It also prevents an ordinary convection current in a fluid there. Radiation can still cross the gap because it does not need particles.
- Reflective surfaces facing the gap
- Shiny surfaces are poor absorbers and emitters in the usual thermal radiation comparison. They reduce the transfer by radiation across the gap, which the vacuum alone cannot prevent.
- Insulating stopper
- A stopper of low conductivity slows conduction at the opening. Closing the opening also limits the exchange of fluid between the contents and the surroundings.
- Neck and supports
- Solid parts that join the inner and outer regions still conduct some energy. The stopper is not a perfect insulator, and the reflective surfaces do not remove all radiation.
Apply the same design twice
A hot drink and a cold drink
- A drink at 80°C in a 20°C room: net energy transfers out of the drink. The flask slows its cooling.
- A drink at 5°C in a 25°C room: net energy transfers into the drink. The same barriers slow its warming.
The second case does not need cold to flow out. Reverse the temperature difference and the direction of net transfer reverses. The features still cut down the transfer routes.
Sometimes the aim is faster transfer
A cooling device may use a conducting metal base and fins. Conduction spreads energy from the hotter component into the metal. The fins give a larger exposed area for transfer to the surroundings.
Air moving past the fins carries energy away. A fan can strengthen this fluid movement when natural circulation is not enough. Radiation also plays a part. Its rate depends on the surface finish, temperature and area. Calling every feature an "insulator" would miss the purpose of this design.
Compare designs under the same conditions
To test the effect of an insulating wrap on a cup, change only that wrap. Keep the cup, amount of liquid, lid, starting temperature, surroundings and measurement method the same. Record temperature against time using the same sensor position and intervals.
Suppose one cup starts at 80°C and another at 60°C in the same room. The temperature differences that drive the transfer are then not the same. Their final readings alone cannot pick out the effect of the wrap. Resetting the starting conditions fixes that problem. Repeating the unequal comparison does not.
Identify where the remaining energy can go: through the cup and lid, into the moving air around it, and by radiation. An improvement should reduce a named route. It should not claim that an extra layer must stop every process.
Match the feature to the mechanism. A vacuum suppresses routes across the gap that need a material medium. A shiny surface reduces transfer by radiation. A solid of low conductivity slows conduction. None of these explains the whole flask by itself.
Check your understanding
Air enters the space that was evacuated between the walls of a vacuum flask. The reflective finishes remain unchanged. What new explanation accounts for faster transfer across this gap?
Show the answer
The air now provides a conduction pathway across the gap and may allow convection within it.
The gas provides a material pathway for conduction and, if the geometry allows circulation, convection. The vacuum had suppressed those routes; radiation and conduction through solid connections were already possible.
Practise an exam question
Write your answer first, then tick the mark points it makes.
Exam-style question
A vacuum flask keeps hot drinks hot. Explain how each of these features reduces energy transfer: the vacuum between the double walls, the silvered surfaces of the walls, and the stopper. [3]
Saved on this browser only. Anyone using this browser can see it.