Lesson 7 of 12 / Nutrition and transport in flowering plants
Light, dark and the compensation point
Does a leaf take in or give out carbon dioxide?
I can explain net gas exchange in light and dark, the compensation point and hydrogencarbonate indicator results.
I can investigate and describe light, CO2 and temperature effects on photosynthesis.Syllabus
Syllabus K327 / K328, Topic 8(h). Investigate and describe light, CO2 and temperature effects on photosynthesis.
About 7 min
Make a guess. You are not marked.
Do plants respire during the day, or only at night?
Show the answer
All the time, day and night.
Respiration never stops. In bright light, photosynthesis takes in carbon dioxide faster than respiration releases it.
The key idea
A leaf respires all the time but photosynthesises only in light. Net gas exchange depends on which process is faster; at the compensation point they are equal.
Hydrogencarbonate indicator shows carbon dioxide concentration. It is red when in equilibrium with normal air, yellow when carbon dioxide rises and purple when carbon dioxide falls.
At the compensation point the rate of photosynthesis equals the rate of respiration. The carbon dioxide used equals the carbon dioxide released, so the indicator stays red.
Net carbon dioxide uptake by a leaf over 24 hours
Shaded: night. Above the dashed line the leaf takes in carbon dioxide; below it the leaf releases carbon dioxide. Illustrative curve, not measured data.
Explanation
A leaf respires all the time, day and night, releasing carbon dioxide and taking in oxygen. In light it also photosynthesises, taking in carbon dioxide and releasing oxygen. What you measure from the outside is net gas exchange: the difference between the two processes.
In the dark only respiration takes place, so the leaf gives out carbon dioxide and takes in oxygen. In bright light the rate of photosynthesis is greater than the rate of respiration, so the leaf takes in carbon dioxide and gives out oxygen overall.
The compensation point is the light intensity at which the rate of photosynthesis equals the rate of respiration. At this light intensity there is no net exchange of carbon dioxide or oxygen. The leaf is still photosynthesising and respiring; the two simply balance.
Over 24 hours, net carbon dioxide uptake is negative at night, rises through zero at the compensation point soon after dawn, peaks around midday and falls back through zero at the compensation point near dusk. A plant gains mass only if, over the whole day, it fixes more carbon by photosynthesis than it releases in respiration.
Hydrogencarbonate indicator lets you see these changes. Its colour depends on the carbon dioxide concentration: red in normal air, yellow when carbon dioxide increases, and purple when carbon dioxide decreases. A leaf in a sealed tube in the dark turns the indicator from red to yellow. In bright light it turns the indicator from red to purple. At the compensation point the indicator stays red. A tube with no leaf is the control: it stays red, showing that the leaf caused the change.
When you describe an indicator result, give both colours: "the indicator changed from red to yellow". Mark schemes often want the starting and final colour, and "turned yellow" alone may lose the mark.
Step by step
- 1
Name both processes
Respiration happens all the time; photosynthesis only in light.
- 2
Compare the rates
Photosynthesis faster: net uptake of carbon dioxide. Respiration faster: net release. Equal: compensation point.
- 3
Link to the indicator
Less carbon dioxide: red to purple. More carbon dioxide: red to yellow. No net change: stays red.
Worked example
Three tubes
Three sealed tubes contain hydrogencarbonate indicator and a leaf. Tube A is in bright light, tube B is in the dark and tube C is in dim light. After two hours A is purple, B is yellow and C is red. Explain the results.
One way to explain it
In A, photosynthesis is faster than respiration, so the leaf removes carbon dioxide and the indicator changes from red to purple. In B there is no photosynthesis; respiration releases carbon dioxide, so the indicator changes from red to yellow. In C the light intensity is at the compensation point: photosynthesis and respiration are equal, so there is no net change in carbon dioxide and the indicator stays red.
Why this answer works
- Give the colour change from and to.
- Compare the rates of the two processes for each tube.
- A control tube without a leaf would show that the leaf caused the changes.
Watch out for this
A student says: "Plants photosynthesise in the day and respire only at night." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
Plants respire all the time. In daylight the carbon dioxide from respiration is used in photosynthesis, so the release is hidden by the faster uptake.
Check your understanding
A leaf in a sealed tube of hydrogencarbonate indicator is kept in dim light. After an hour the indicator is still red, the same as a control tube without a leaf. What is the best explanation?
Show the answer
The rate of photosynthesis equals the rate of respiration.
This is the compensation point: carbon dioxide used equals carbon dioxide released, so there is no net change.
Quick recall
Does a leaf take in or give out carbon dioxide?