Lesson 11 of 11 / Biological molecules
Sources of error and their effect
Why does "human error" earn no marks?
I can state a source of error with its effect on the result, and give an improvement that fixes it.
I can investigate and explain temperature and pH effects on enzyme reactions.Syllabus
Syllabus K327 / K328, Topic 3(e). Investigate and explain temperature and pH effects on enzyme reactions.
About 3 min
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A student writes "human error" as the source of error in her amylase experiment. Why does this earn no mark?
Show the answer
It names no exact problem and no effect.
A source of error must say what in the method went wrong and which way it pushed the reading.
The key idea
Every source of error needs its effect: name the exact problem, say which way it pushes the reading, then give an improvement that fixes that problem.
A source of error is a feature of the method that makes a reading differ from its true value.
Explore the idea
Which way does each error push the time?
Problem: The blue-black colour fades gradually, so the end point is recorded late. Effect: The time is too long, so the calculated rate is too low. Improvement: Compare each spot with a reference spot of iodine and water.
Invented values that show only the direction of each error. All three errors make the recorded time longer than the true time.
Explanation
Sources of error must come with their effect. "Human error" scores nothing. Name the exact problem and say which way it pushes the reading.
Judging the end point by eye is a common source of error. The blue-black colour fades gradually, so you may record the end point late. The time is then too long and the calculated rate too low. To improve, compare each spot with a reference spot of iodine and water.
A second is temperature. If the enzyme and starch are mixed before both reach the water-bath temperature, the reaction starts at a lower temperature, so the time is too long. Leave both solutions in the water bath for 5 minutes before mixing.
A third is the sampling interval. Sampling every 30 s means the true end point could be up to 30 s earlier than recorded. Sample every 10 s instead.
Step by step
- 1
Name the exact problem
Say what in the method goes wrong, such as an end point that is hard to judge.
- 2
Give the effect
Say whether the reading becomes too high or too low, and what that does to the rate.
- 3
Give the improvement
The improvement must fix that particular problem, such as warming both solutions before mixing.
Worked example
Fix the cold-start problem
A student times how long amylase takes to digest starch at 40 degrees C. She mixes room-temperature solutions and then puts the tube in the 40 degrees C water bath. State the source of error, its effect on the time and an improvement.
One way to explain it
The mixture starts below 40 degrees C, so for the first part of the experiment the enzyme works at a lower temperature. The recorded time is too long, so the rate is underestimated. Leave the starch and the amylase in separate tubes in the 40 degrees C water bath for 5 minutes before mixing.
Why this answer works
- Name the exact problem, not "human error".
- Give the direction of the effect on the reading and on the rate.
- The improvement fixes that particular problem.
Watch out for this
A student says: "Repeating the experiment removes a source of error." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
Repeats let you spot an anomalous reading and calculate a mean. An error built into the method, such as a late end point, affects every repeat in the same way. Change the method to fix it.
Check your understanding
A student lifts the tube out of a 40 degrees C water bath each time she takes a sample. The room is at 25 degrees C. What is the effect on the time for starch to disappear?
Show the answer
The mixture cools, so the reaction slows and the time is too long.
Below the optimum, a lower temperature means fewer effective collisions. The exact problem is cooling and its effect is a longer time.
Quick recall
Why does "human error" earn no marks?