Lesson 9 of 11 / Biological molecules
Drawing a results table
What earns the marks in a results table?
I can draw a results table with correct columns, headings, units and decimal places.
I can investigate and explain temperature and pH effects on enzyme reactions.Syllabus
Syllabus K327 / K328, Topic 3(e). Investigate and explain temperature and pH effects on enzyme reactions.
About 4 min
Make a guess. You are not marked.
You time a reaction with a stopwatch and get 43 seconds. Where does the unit "s" go in your results table?
Show the answer
In the column heading only.
Headings are written quantity / unit, such as "Time / s". The cells then hold only numbers.
The key idea
A results table puts the independent variable in the first column, the unit only in each heading, and every reading in a column to the same number of decimal places.
The independent variable is the factor you change on purpose. The dependent variable is the factor you measure. Compare the draft table with the corrected one below.
Explore the idea
Would this table earn the marks?
| Temp | Time | Time | Time |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 | 182 s | 176 | 179.0 |
| 30 | 94 | 90 s | 98 |
| 40 | 41 | 45 | 43.0 |
| 50 | 66 | 71 | 64 |
| 60 | 300 | 300 | 300 |
Find five problems before you switch to the marked layout: look at the headings, the units, the decimal places, the missing column and the 60 degrees C row.
Control: the only difference between the two tubes is that the control enzyme was boiled, which denatures it. Starch remains in the control tube, so active amylase, not heat or time, made the starch disappear in the test tube.
Original practice values, not measured data. The two tubes look the same at the start; only the iodine spots at the end show which one had active enzyme.
Explanation
A practical question usually gives marks for the table before it gives marks for the biology. Rule the table with a border and lines between columns. Put the independent variable in the first column, for example temperature. Put each repeat of the dependent variable in its own column, for example the time for starch to disappear. Add a mean column on the right.
Each heading has a quantity and a unit, written "Temperature / degrees C" or "Time for starch to disappear / s". The unit goes in the heading only, never in each cell. Every reading in a column has the same number of decimal places, matching the instrument. A stopwatch read to the nearest second gives whole numbers, so "43" is right and "43.0" or "43 s" in a cell is wrong. Give a mean to the same number of decimal places as the readings.
Some results have no end point in the time you allow. If starch is still present after 300 s, record "> 300" rather than inventing a number. Do not use it to calculate a mean or a rate. Then the reader knows the reaction was too slow to measure.
Step by step
- 1
Lay out the columns
Independent variable first, then repeats, then mean. Rule the lines.
- 2
Write the headings
Quantity / unit in each heading. No units in the cells.
- 3
Check the numbers
Same decimal places down each column, and the mean to the same number of places.
Worked example
Fill in the mean column
Amylase digests starch at 30 degrees C in 85 s, 88 s and 91 s in three repeats. The stopwatch was read to the nearest second. What goes in the mean column, and what is its heading?
One way to explain it
The mean is (85 + 88 + 91) / 3 = 88. Write 88 in the cell, with no unit and no decimal place, under the heading "Mean time for starch to disappear / s".
Why this answer works
- Add the three repeats and divide by 3.
- The readings are whole seconds, so the mean is a whole number too.
- The unit belongs in the heading, not in the cell.
Watch out for this
A student says: "Writing the unit after every number in a results table makes it clearer." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
The unit goes once, in the column heading, written as quantity / unit. A cell holds only the number, so "43" is right and "43 s" is wrong.
Check your understanding
A stopwatch is read to the nearest second. Which entry is correct for one cell under the heading "Time for starch to disappear / s"?
Show the answer
43
The cell holds only the number, to the precision of the instrument. The unit is already in the heading.
Quick recall
What earns the marks in a results table?