Skip to notes
8873 / 2027
Data and Experimental Skills

Lesson 3 of 3

Evaluate evidence

Explain limitations and target improvements.

A-Level 8873, revised syllabus (2026-2027)

  • I can find patterns and draw inferences.Syllabus

    Syllabus 8873, B4. Find patterns and draw inferences

  • I can apply chemistry to unfamiliar situations.Syllabus

    Syllabus 8873, B6. Apply chemistry to unfamiliar situations

  • I can integrate knowledge.Syllabus

    Syllabus 8873, B7. Integrate knowledge

  • I can evaluate information and hypotheses.Syllabus

    Syllabus 8873, B8. Evaluate information and hypotheses

  • I can justify a conclusion or action.Syllabus

    Syllabus 8873, B9. Justify a conclusion or action

  • I can recognise model limitations.Syllabus

    Syllabus 8873, B10. Recognise model limitations

Evaluate evidence and explain the direction of an error

An improvement is useful when it targets a specific limitation.

Make a guess. You are not marked.

Three repeat timings are 41 s, 43 s and 58 s. What should be done first?

  1. Delete 58 s without comment, since it is clearly wrong
  2. Average all three, since every reading counts equally
  3. Look for a cause of the 58 s run and repeat it
Show the answer

Look for a cause of the 58 s run and repeat it

The 58 s run does not agree with the other two. Check the method and repeat it before deciding whether to leave it out, and record why.

Different limitations need different responses
IssueEffect on evidenceUseful response
Random variationRepeated results scatter unpredictablyRepeat independent measurements; compare their spread and use a justified mean
Systematic biasResults are displaced consistently, for example by an incorrect calibrationCheck against a suitable standard or correct the apparatus/method; repetition alone does not remove the bias
Uncontrolled variableTwo possible causes change togetherHold that variable constant or design an additional comparison
Limited range or sampleA relationship may be supported only locallyCollect appropriate additional values; restrict the conclusion to the evidence

Accuracy concerns closeness to a valid reference value; precision concerns the closeness of repeated measurements. A tightly grouped set can still be inaccurate. An anomalous point is a reason to investigate the method and repeat a measurement, not permission to remove inconvenient evidence silently. Record an exclusion and its reason.

Worked exampleFollow an error through the calculation

An acid in a burette neutralises a known amount of alkali in a flask, in a 1:1 ratio. The burette tip initially contains an air bubble that fills with acid during the titration. What happens to the calculated acid concentration?

Try it first. Then show the worked stepsHide the worked steps
  1. Some liquid leaving the graduated barrel fills the tip instead of entering the flask. The recorded titre is larger than the acid volume delivered to the flask.
  2. The known alkali amount still determines the acid amount needed for neutralisation.
  3. Calculated acid concentration = known reacting amount / recorded acid volume. A denominator that is too large gives a concentration that is too low.
Answer

The calculated acid concentration is too low in this arrangement. Fill the tip before taking the initial reading. If the unknown were instead in the flask, the calculation and error direction would need to be reconsidered.

Write evaluation as a causal chain: limitation -> affected measurement -> effect on the calculated result -> targeted improvement. "Human error" and "use better equipment" do not identify what happened. For example, gas escaping before collection lowers measured gas volume; assembling a closed collection system before starting the reaction addresses that loss.

A result must be repeatable before anyone trusts it. In March 1989, Martin Fleischmann and Stanley Pons of the University of Utah announced "cold fusion" in a test tube. Physicists in several countries tried to repeat their results and failed.

Check your understanding

A thermometer reads 2 degrees too high at every temperature. Will averaging five readings remove that error?

  1. No. Averaging works with an even number of readings, so take six readings instead.
  2. No. Averaging reduces random scatter, but a fixed offset stays in every reading.
  3. Yes. Five readings are enough for their errors to cancel each other out.
Show the answer

No. Averaging reduces random scatter, but a fixed offset stays in every reading.

Every reading is 2 degrees high, so their average is too. Calibrate the thermometer against a reference. A temperature change measured with the same thermometer can cancel a constant offset.

Watch out for this

A student says: "Repeating the experiment and averaging the results makes the results reliable." What is wrong with this?

Show the answer

Repeats let you check whether the results agree. A mean only reduces the effect of random scatter or an odd result, and it cannot remove a systematic error. A June 2022 Cambridge report says simply averaging repeats does not ensure the results are reliable.

Exam-style question

Evaluate a claim from rate data. [4]

A supplier claims that adding a new material, M, doubles the rate of a gas-forming reaction. All runs use the same reactant amounts and apparatus. The table gives one run for each condition. A time difference of 1 s is within the timing variation seen.
Does M increase the rate?
RunTreatment and temperatureTime to collect the same gas volume
AWithout M, 25 °C48 s
BWith M, 35 °C24 s
CWithout M, 35 °C25 s
(a) Explain why runs A and B alone cannot show that M increases the rate. [1]
(b) Use runs B and C to evaluate the claim. [2]
(c) Describe a further experiment that would test the claim. [1]

Saved on this browser only. Anyone using this browser can see it.