What this lesson teaches
I can judge the outcomes of economic change in Southeast Asia for growth, equity and economic nationalism.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of economic change across different contexts and over time
Make a guess
Burma cut itself off from foreign trade and investment to be self-reliant. What do you think the result was?
- It became the region's richest and most independent economy.
- It became one of Asia's poorest countries.
- It grew as fast as Singapore by using its own resources.
Show the answer
It became one of Asia's poorest countries.
Strict self-reliance cost Burma dearly. Most other states gained more local control while still relying on foreign money and markets.
Governments gained more control over their economies, but most still relied on foreign money and markets. Countries that pursued self-reliance most strictly paid the highest price.
Economic nationalism means aiming for self-sufficiency and local control. The goal is to depend less on foreigners.
Self-sufficiency in food was a key aim. Indonesia became self-sufficient in rice in 1984, a major achievement, although it had to import rice again in later years.
Burma pursued self-reliance most strictly. It cut itself off from foreign trade and investment, and it became one of Asia's poorest countries.
Local control of business grew in some countries. In Malaysia, a state firm took charge of oil and gas.
Malaysia also built a national car. Proton's first model, the Saga, came out in 1985, protected by high taxes on imported cars.
Yet growth still depended on foreign money and markets. The 1997 crisis added to foreign influence. The IMF set conditions, and foreign firms bought struggling local ones.
- Rice
- Indonesia self-sufficient in 1984.
- Malaysia
- Foreign ownership about 63% (1970), 25.4% (1990), 32.7% (1999).
- Proton
- A protected national car.
Real examples to use
Petronas, 1974
Malaysia's Petroleum Development Act of 1974 gave the new state oil company, Petronas, ownership of the country's oil and gas.
Worked example: Who owned Malaysia's companies, 1970 to 1999
In 1970 foreigners owned about 63 per cent of the share capital of Malaysian companies. The NEP aimed to cut this to 30 per cent by 1990.
- Buying control: on 7 September 1981, the state fund Permodalan Nasional Berhad bought control of Guthrie within hours. Guthrie was a British plantation firm, traded in London.
- The result: by 1990 the foreign share had fallen to 25.4 per cent, beating the target.
- The reversal: Malaysia then courted foreign investment for growth and, later, for recovery from the 1997 crisis. By 1999 the foreign share had risen to 32.7 per cent.
- Judgement: local control rose sharply, but the government traded some of it back for growth.
Watch out for this
Economic nationalism meant cutting all foreign links.
Most governments aimed for more local control while still welcoming foreign investment. Only Burma tried full self-reliance, and it failed.
Check your understanding
What does Burma's experience show about self-reliance?
- Self-reliance made it one of the richest countries in Asia.
- Cutting off foreign trade and investment left it poor.
- It depended heavily on multinationals for jobs.
Show the answer
Cutting off foreign trade and investment left it poor.
Right. Isolation came at a high price.
Check your understanding
Malaysia's foreign ownership share fell to 25.4 per cent in 1990 but rose to 32.7 per cent by 1999. What best explains the rise?
- The NEP required foreign firms to raise their share of ownership.
- Malaysia sought foreign investment for growth and recovery.
- Malaysians were banned from buying shares in their own companies.
Show the answer
Malaysia sought foreign investment for growth and recovery.
Right. Control was traded against growth, so the share moved with the government's priorities.