Weighing the outcomes

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge the outcomes of economic change in Southeast Asia for growth, equity and economic nationalism.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of economic change across different contexts and over time

Make a guess

Southeast Asian governments aimed for growth, equity and economic nationalism. Which aim do you think they achieved most fully?

  1. Economic nationalism, as they cut foreign ties.
  2. Equity, as wealth was shared evenly everywhere.
  3. Growth, more fully than equity or independence.
Show the answer

Growth, more fully than equity or independence.

Growth was widely achieved. Equity was partial, and most economies stayed dependent on foreign capital and markets.

Most governments achieved growth more fully than equity or economic independence. The aims often had to be traded against each other.

Growth was the aim most widely achieved, especially in Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand and Indonesia.

Equity was achieved in part. Poverty fell steeply in the fast-growing economies, but gaps between regions and within groups often grew.

Economic nationalism was achieved least. Most economies stayed dependent on foreign capital and markets, and the 1997 crisis showed how much outside forces still mattered.

The aims involved trade-offs. Burma put self-reliance first and lost growth. Malaysia tried to balance growth with ethnic equity, with partial success.

Outcomes changed over time. Most gains came between the late 1960s and 1997. The crisis reversed part of them before recovery began in 1999.

Most achieved
Growth.
Partly achieved
Equity.
Least achieved
Economic independence.

Worked example: Singapore's choice, 1965 to 1997

Singapore chose fast growth through foreign investment. Its record tests whether all three aims could be met at once.

  1. Growth: met. In 1995 World Bank figures put Singapore's income per person at about 24,900 US dollars, above Britain's 23,300.
  2. Equity: largely met through public housing. The share of households owning their homes rose from 58.8 per cent in 1980 to 87.5 per cent in 1990 (SingStat).
  3. Control: foreign firms led manufacturing. Foreign direct investment, money foreign firms put into businesses, equalled about 15 per cent of GDP in 1990. In Malaysia it was about 5 per cent.
  4. Judgement: Singapore met growth and much of equity by giving up local ownership of much of its industry. The state kept control through its own firms.

Watch out for this

A country that grew fast achieved all its economic aims.

Fast growth often came with greater inequality and dependence on foreign capital. Judge each aim separately.

Check your understanding

Which aim did Singapore trade away for fast growth?

  1. Fast economic growth
  2. Political stability and order at home
  3. Local ownership of much of its manufacturing
Show the answer

Local ownership of much of its manufacturing

Right. It relied on multinational companies.

Check your understanding

A student judges Southeast Asia's economic outcomes using figures from 1996 only. What is the main weakness?

  1. It misses the 1997 crisis and the recovery that followed.
  2. Figures from 1996 are too recent for historians to trust.
  3. Growth had not yet begun by 1996.
Show the answer

It misses the 1997 crisis and the recovery that followed.

Right. Outcomes changed over time, so a judgement needs more than one point in time.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready