What this lesson teaches
I can judge the outcomes of economic change in Southeast Asia for growth, equity and economic nationalism.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of economic change across different contexts and over time
Make a guess
Poverty fell sharply in fast-growing Southeast Asian economies. Do you think inequality fell too?
- Yes, less poverty means there is less inequality as well.
- Not always; gaps between town, country and regions often grew.
- No, because poverty did not really fall anywhere.
Show the answer
Not always; gaps between town, country and regions often grew.
Bangkok's incomes rose far faster than the rural northeast. Falling poverty and falling inequality are different things.
Inequality often persisted or grew, between town and country, between regions and between ethnic groups. Malaysia did most to narrow ethnic gaps.
Income distribution is about how evenly income is shared. It can worsen even while poverty falls, if the rich gain faster than the poor.
Economists measure it with the Gini index. It runs from 0, where everyone has the same income, to 100, where one person has it all.
Gaps between town and country grew in several countries. In Thailand, incomes in Bangkok rose far faster than in the rural northeast.
Malaysia set out to reduce ethnic inequality. Under the NEP, Bumiputera ownership of company shares rose from 2.4 per cent in 1970 to 19.3 per cent in 1990. This fell short of the 30 per cent target.
The income gap between groups narrowed too. But the NEP widened gaps within the Malay community, as well-connected Malay businessmen gained most.
In Indonesia, overall inequality was moderate. But wealth was concentrated among Suharto's family and allies and large Chinese-owned conglomerates, or business groups. In the Philippines, a few landowning families held much of the wealth.
- Malay ownership
- 2.4% (1970) to 19.3% (1990); target 30%.
- Thailand
- Bangkok pulls ahead of the northeast.
- Indonesia
- Wealth concentrated among cronies and conglomerates.
Real examples to use
Malaysia's Gini coefficient
Official figures, on a scale of 0 to 1, give 0.513 in 1970, 0.442 in 1989 and 0.443 in 1999. Inequality fell under the NEP, then stopped falling.
Worked example: Thailand's boom, 1988 to 1992
Thailand's economy grew by more than 10 per cent a year from 1988 to 1992, and poverty fell. Did everyone gain equally?
- Inequality: World Bank estimates put Thailand's Gini index at 43.8 in 1988 and 47.9 in 1992. A higher figure means a less equal share.
- The top: the richest tenth of Thais took 35.3 per cent of income in 1988 and 38.6 per cent in 1992.
- Later: by 1996 the Gini index had eased to 42.9.
- Judgement: in the fastest years of the boom, poverty fell while inequality grew. Judge equity on both measures, not on poverty alone.
Watch out for this
Falling poverty means that inequality also fell.
Poverty can fall while the rich gain even faster. Thailand cut poverty but saw the gap between regions grow.
Check your understanding
What happened to Malay ownership of companies under the NEP?
- It fell as Chinese and foreign firms bought up Malay-owned shares.
- It reached the 30% target by 1980.
- It rose from about 2% in 1970 to about 19% in 1990.
Show the answer
It rose from about 2% in 1970 to about 19% in 1990.
Right. It rose but missed the 30% target.
Check your understanding
In 1970 the average Chinese household in Malaysia earned 2.29 times as much as the average Bumiputera household. In 1989 it earned 1.74 times as much. What does this show?
- The gap widened, since both figures are above 1.
- The income gap between the two groups narrowed.
- Chinese household incomes fell between 1970 and 1989.
Show the answer
The income gap between the two groups narrowed.
Right. Bumiputera incomes rose faster than Chinese incomes, so the ratio fell.