The role of government: aims and strategies

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge which factors, at home and abroad, did most to shape economic change in Southeast Asia.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors shaping economic change in different contexts and over time

Make a guess

Southeast Asian economies grew at very different speeds after independence. What do you think did most to explain the difference?

  1. Governments' choices of economic strategy.
  2. Luck, since governments followed the same plan.
  3. Climate, since hotter countries grew more slowly.
Show the answer

Governments' choices of economic strategy.

Strategies ranged from Burma's state socialism to Singapore's welcome for foreign investment, and outcomes diverged.

Governments chose strategies ranging from state socialism to welcoming foreign investment. Their choices did more than anything else to explain why economies diverged.

Every government set economic aims, but strategies differed. Some used the state to run the economy. Others used it to help private and foreign firms.

Singapore's government planned growth with care. Its Economic Development Board, set up in 1961, drew in big foreign firms. The state also built industrial estates and public housing. It ran firms through Temasek Holdings, set up in 1974.

Suharto relied on economists trained in the USA, often called the "Berkeley Mafia". They tamed inflation and drew in investment. Oil money from the 1970s then paid for schools, roads and rice programmes.

Malaysia's New Economic Policy used the state to raise Malay ownership and incomes. It set up state firms such as PERNAS in 1969 and the national oil company, Petronas, in 1974.

Burma chose state socialism. After 1962 the government took over business and closed the economy to the world. It ran it badly. By 1987 the UN classed Burma as one of the world's least developed countries.

EDB
Singapore, 1961.
Petronas
Malaysia, 1974.
Burma
Classed by the UN as least developed, 1987.

Real examples to use

Singapore: EDB, 1 August 1961

The Economic Development Board, first chaired by Hon Sui Sen, courted foreign factory owners. Temasek Holdings, set up on 25 June 1974, took over 35 state companies.

Malaysia: Petronas, 17 August 1974

The national oil company gave the state control of oil and gas money to fund the New Economic Policy.

Worked example: Suharto's technocrats, 1966 to 1969

In 1966 Indonesia's prices were rising by hundreds of per cent a year. Suharto gave economic policy to a team led by Widjojo Nitisastro.

  1. Budget: the team cut spending. It ended the deficits that the state had covered by printing money.
  2. Investment: a new law in January 1967 invited foreign firms back.
  3. Result: World Bank data show inflation down to about 15 per cent in 1969. That year Indonesia's first five-year plan began.
  4. Judgement: a new strategy turned the economy round before the oil boom, helped by Western aid.

Watch out for this

More government intervention always meant slower growth.

Singapore's government intervened heavily, but in support of markets and investment. Burma's intervention failed because it shut out markets and investment.

Check your understanding

What did Singapore's Economic Development Board do?

  1. It nationalised the main industries and ran them for profit.
  2. It attracted multinational companies to invest in Singapore.
  3. It ran rice farms and fisheries.
Show the answer

It attracted multinational companies to invest in Singapore.

Right. It drove export-led growth.

Check your understanding

Indonesia's inflation fell from hundreds of per cent in 1966 to about 15 per cent in 1969. Which factor does this case best support?

  1. Private business, because Chinese firms took over the budget.
  2. The role of government, through a new economic strategy.
  3. Domestic conditions, because Indonesia found new oil fields.
Show the answer

The role of government, through a new economic strategy.

Right. The same country, with the same resources, changed course when its policy changed.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready