What this lesson teaches
I can judge which factors, at home and abroad, did most to shape economic change in Southeast Asia.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors shaping economic change in different contexts and over time
Make a guess
Indonesia had large oil reserves; Singapore had almost no natural resources. Do you think resource-rich countries always grew fastest?
- No, resources helped but could also become a trap.
- No, because resources did not help economies grow.
- Yes, natural resources brought the fastest growth.
Show the answer
No, resources helped but could also become a trap.
Indonesia was hit when oil prices fell in 1986, while Singapore grew through trade, skills and foreign investment.
Natural resources, population, skills and political stability shaped what each economy could do. They set the opportunities and limits for governments.
Natural resources mattered. Oil and gas gave Indonesia, Malaysia and Brunei large revenues, especially when oil prices rose in the 1970s. Fertile land let Thailand and Burma export rice.
Resources could also be a trap. Heavy dependence on oil left Indonesia exposed when prices fell in 1986. Countries with few resources, such as Singapore, had to rely on trade, skills and foreign investment.
Population size shaped markets and labour. Large populations, as in Indonesia and the Philippines, gave a big home market and cheap labour. They also meant many people to feed and employ. Small Singapore had almost no home market, which pushed it towards exports.
Skills and infrastructure mattered. Singapore and Malaysia inherited ports, roads and an English-educated workforce from British rule. Indonesia and Burma had far fewer trained people at independence.
Political stability affected investment. Fighting in Burma and the turmoil of Sukarno's last years drove investors away. Stable governments in Singapore and Malaysia drew them in.
- Oil
- Indonesia, Malaysia and Brunei.
- Rice
- Thailand and Burma.
- Few resources
- Singapore.
Real examples to use
Singapore's lack of resources
With no hinterland and almost no home market, Singapore turned swampy Jurong into a large industrial estate in the 1960s to attract export factories.
Burma's lost advantages
Rich in rice, teak and gems, Burma had been the world's largest rice exporter before the Second World War. Under army rule it fell far behind its neighbours.
Worked example: Indonesia's oil, 1970 to 1985
World Bank data show that fuels made up about 33 per cent of Indonesia's merchandise exports in 1970. After oil prices rose in 1973 and 1974, they made up about 75 per cent in 1975.
- Opportunity: by the early 1980s oil and gas paid for most of the government's budget.
- Trap: in 1985 fuels were still about two-thirds of exports, so the economy rose and fell with the oil price.
- Contrast: Singapore had no oil of its own, so it had to build industry and trade from the start.
- Judgement: resources gave Indonesia both choices and risks. What mattered was how the government used them.
Watch out for this
Countries rich in resources always grew fastest.
Burma had rich land and resources but stagnated, while resource-poor Singapore grew fastest. Policies mattered more than resources.
Check your understanding
Why did Singapore's small size push it towards export-led growth?
- It had large oil reserves to pay for building new factories.
- Its neighbours banned trade with it after 1965.
- Its home market was too small to support large industries.
Show the answer
Its home market was too small to support large industries.
Right. It had to sell to the world.
Check your understanding
In 1985 fuels were still about two-thirds of Indonesia's exports. Why was this a risk?
- A fall in oil prices would cut export earnings sharply.
- Oil would soon run out completely by the late 1980s.
- Oil exports were banned by Western countries in 1985.
Show the answer
A fall in oil prices would cut export earnings sharply.
Right. When oil prices collapsed in 1986, Indonesia had to change course.