How far should the state intervene?

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge which factors, at home and abroad, did most to shape economic change in Southeast Asia.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors shaping economic change in different contexts and over time

Make a guess

Singapore's government intervened heavily in its economy and grew fast. Do you think more intervention always meant faster growth?

  1. No, the kind of intervention mattered as much as the amount.
  2. No, intervention slowed growth down.
  3. Yes, the more a state did, the faster it grew.
Show the answer

No, the kind of intervention mattered as much as the amount.

Support for markets worked in Singapore and Malaysia. Crony control under Marcos and rigid state control in Burma did not.

The kind of intervention mattered as much as the amount. Intervention that supported markets worked; rigid state control or capture by cronies did not.

Thailand intervened lightly. Its central bank kept prices steady, and its Board of Investment offered tax breaks. But private firms led growth.

Singapore and Malaysia intervened heavily, but in ways that helped markets work. They built roads and ports, trained workers and courted investors.

In the Philippines under Marcos, intervention served cronies, his friends and allies. They were given control of sugar, coconut and other industries. Foreign debt rose to about 26 billion dollars by 1985. The economy shrank by about 7 per cent in both 1984 and 1985.

Indonesia mixed both. Technocrats ran sound policies on inflation and the budget. But Suharto's family and business allies won monopolies and contracts.

Vietnam showed how a change of strategy changed results. Rigid central planning failed. The Doi Moi reforms from 1986 allowed markets and foreign investment, and growth took off.

Light touch
Thailand.
Crony capitalism
The Philippines under Marcos.
Doi Moi
Vietnam, 1986.

Real examples to use

Prices in 1984

World Bank data show Thai consumer prices rising by about 1 per cent in 1984, while Philippine prices rose by about 50 per cent.

Worked example: Vietnam's Doi Moi, 1986 to 1997

In December 1986, with prices rising by hundreds of per cent a year, Vietnam's Communist Party congress adopted Doi Moi, which means renovation.

  1. Markets: farmers and firms were allowed to sell more of their output at market prices.
  2. Investment: a law to attract foreign investment followed in December 1987.
  3. Result: World Bank data show growth averaging about 8 per cent a year from 1990 to 1997.
  4. Judgement: the same ruling party got far better results once it stopped trying to control everything.

Watch out for this

The Philippines grew slowly because its government did too little.

Under Marcos the government intervened a great deal, but mainly to benefit cronies. The problem was the purpose of intervention, not its amount.

Check your understanding

What did Vietnam's Doi Moi reforms of 1986 show?

  1. Changing strategy towards markets could quickly improve results.
  2. Central planning worked better than markets in poor countries.
  3. Foreign investment was harmful to growth.
Show the answer

Changing strategy towards markets could quickly improve results.

Right. Growth took off after reform.

Check your understanding

Marcos's government intervened heavily, yet the economy shrank in 1984 and 1985. What does this show?

  1. The Philippines did too little to manage its economy.
  2. Any government intervention always harms economic growth.
  3. The purpose of intervention mattered more than its amount.
Show the answer

The purpose of intervention mattered more than its amount.

Right. Intervention that served cronies harmed growth, while intervention that supported markets helped.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready