What this lesson teaches
I can judge which factors, at home and abroad, did most to shape economic change in Southeast Asia.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors shaping economic change in different contexts and over time
Make a guess
Chinese family groups such as the Salim Group grew into huge conglomerates. Do you think they succeeded independently of governments?
- No, governments owned and ran these conglomerates.
- Yes, they did not need help from governments.
- No, many prospered through close ties to rulers.
Show the answer
No, many prospered through close ties to rulers.
The Salim Group won valuable licences through links to Suharto. Business success often depended on government favour.
Local family firms, especially Chinese-owned groups, and foreign multinationals drove much of the growth. Their success often depended on links with governments.
Chinese family firms were central across the region. Charoen Pokphand in Thailand, the Salim Group in Indonesia and Robert Kuok's firms in Malaysia grew into large conglomerates. A conglomerate is a group of firms in many trades under one owner.
Many grew rich through close ties to rulers. The Salim Group won rich licences through its link to Suharto.
Big foreign firms, or multinationals, brought money, skills and links to world markets. American, Japanese and European electronics firms built factories in Singapore, Penang and Thailand.
Governments also made new business classes. Malaysia's NEP helped Malays into business through state contracts, licences and shares.
Private businesses could also do harm. Cronies in the Philippines ran industries badly. Heavy borrowing by private firms in Thailand and Indonesia helped cause the 1997 crisis.
- Charoen Pokphand
- Thailand.
- Salim Group
- Indonesia; ties to Suharto.
- Multinationals
- Electronics in Singapore, Penang and Thailand.
Real examples to use
Intel in Penang, 1972
Intel opened its first factory outside the USA in Penang's Bayan Lepas free trade zone in 1972. It had about 100 workers and cost 1.6 million dollars.
Malaysia's NEP target, 1971
The New Economic Policy aimed for Malays and other Bumiputera to own 30 per cent of company shares by 1990. In 1970 they had owned only a few per cent. By 1990 they owned less than a fifth.
Worked example: The Salim Group, 1969 to 1998
Liem Sioe Liong had supplied the army in Central Java in the 1950s, when Suharto was a commander there. Once Suharto took power, their ties paid off.
- Licence: from 1969 his Bogasari company won the right to mill the wheat that Bulog, the state food agency, imported. It came to mill most of Indonesia's flour.
- Growth: the group spread into cement, banking and instant noodles. It became one of Asia's biggest business groups.
- Fall: in May 1998, as Suharto fell, rioters burned Liem's house in Jakarta, and the group's bank faced a run.
- Judgement: private business drove growth, but the group's fortunes rose and fell with Suharto's.
Watch out for this
Private businesses succeeded independently of governments.
Many of the largest firms grew through licences, monopolies and contracts from governments. Business success and political connections were closely linked.
Check your understanding
How did the Salim Group prosper in Indonesia?
- Through close ties to Suharto that brought licences and monopolies
- By exporting rice to Burma
- By refusing to work with the government and relying on exports
Show the answer
Through close ties to Suharto that brought licences and monopolies
Right. Political links shaped business success.
Check your understanding
Intel opened its first factory outside the USA in Penang in 1972. What does this show about multinationals?
- They replaced the state as Malaysia's main planner.
- They brought money, jobs and links to world markets.
- They mostly made goods to sell inside Malaysia.
Show the answer
They brought money, jobs and links to world markets.
Right. Malaysia's free trade zone drew Intel in, and electronics became a major export.