What this lesson teaches
I can judge which factors did most to transform the economies of Japan and China over time.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors that contributed to the economic transformation of Japan and China over time
Make a guess
Japanese firms in keiretsu groups owned shares in each other. How do you think this helped them?
- They could invest for the long term without fearing takeovers.
- It let one family control a whole industry.
- It let them pay no taxes on their profits.
Show the answer
They could invest for the long term without fearing takeovers.
A main bank gave patient finance, and linked suppliers were reliable, so firms aimed for growth over quick profit.
Keiretsu business groups gave firms patient finance, reliable suppliers and protection from takeovers, so they could invest for the long term.
A keiretsu is a group of firms linked by owning shares in each other. Large groups such as Mitsubishi, Mitsui and Sumitomo formed around a "main bank". Other keiretsu linked a big manufacturer such as Toyota with its many suppliers.
The main bank lent to group firms and watched over them. Because firms owned each other's shares, they did not fear takeovers. They could aim for long-term growth and market share instead of quick profits.
Supplier keiretsu built close, lasting relationships. Toyota and its suppliers developed "just-in-time" production, which cut waste and raised quality.
Inside large firms, lifetime employment, pay by seniority and company unions built loyalty. Firms could train workers knowing they would stay. These practices covered mainly men in large firms.
The system had costs. It was closed to outsiders, and the USA complained that keiretsu blocked American exports. Banks also kept weak firms alive, which added to the bad-loan problem after 1990.
- Keiretsu
- Groups of firms linked by shareholdings, often around a main bank.
- Just-in-time
- Toyota's system with close suppliers.
- Three treasures
- Lifetime jobs, seniority pay, company unions.
Real examples to use
Mitsubishi, Mitsui and Sumitomo
These groups each linked a bank, a trading company and manufacturers through shared shares, the classic keiretsu form.
Mazda's rescue, mid-1970s
When the oil shock hit sales of its fuel-hungry rotary-engine cars, its main bank, Sumitomo, sent in managers and arranged loans.
Worked example: Toyota and its suppliers, 1963
In 1963 Toyota made kanban, its card system for ordering parts, standard at all its plants. Each card asked for only the parts needed next. Toyota's own history says the system was "widely adopted even by suppliers".
- Network: group suppliers, such as Nippondenso, made parts nearby and delivered them often.
- Trust: long ties and shared shares meant suppliers could invest for Toyota's needs without fear of losing its orders.
- Result: little stock was held, so waste fell and faults showed up quickly.
- Judgement: the keiretsu tie made just-in-time possible. A firm buying from strangers could not run on such tight supplies.
Watch out for this
Keiretsu were the same as the pre-war zaibatsu.
Zaibatsu were controlled by families through holding companies. Keiretsu were looser groups linked by shareholdings and banks, with no single family in control.
Check your understanding
Why could keiretsu firms focus on long-term growth?
- Shared shareholdings blocked takeovers, and main banks gave patient credit.
- They were owned by the government and could not go bankrupt.
- They paid no taxes on profits they reinvested.
Show the answer
Shared shareholdings blocked takeovers, and main banks gave patient credit.
Right. They faced less pressure for quick profits.
Check your understanding
Toyota's just-in-time system kept very little stock. Why did it depend on keiretsu ties?
- A keiretsu law forced suppliers to sell parts at a loss.
- The government delivered the parts to Toyota's plants.
- Suppliers in long, trusted ties could deliver exactly when needed.
Show the answer
Suppliers in long, trusted ties could deliver exactly when needed.
Right. Trust let both sides plan around each other.