What this lesson teaches
I can judge which factors did most to transform the economies of Japan and China over time.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors that contributed to the economic transformation of Japan and China over time
Make a guess
Japan's Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MITI) guided growth from 1949. How do you think it did this?
- It left economic decisions to the free market.
- It owned and ran the factories, like a communist state.
- It chose key industries and steered money and technology to them.
Show the answer
It chose key industries and steered money and technology to them.
MITI controlled foreign currency and technology licences and gave guidance firms usually followed.
The state guided growth by choosing key industries, steering savings to them and protecting them while they grew.
The Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MITI), created in 1949, led industrial policy. It chose industries for growth: first steel, shipbuilding and chemicals, and later cars and electronics.
MITI had real power in the 1950s and 1960s. It decided who could buy foreign currency and foreign technology. It also gave "administrative guidance": advice, not law, that firms mostly followed.
The state steered savings into industry. Money saved in the postal savings system was lent through government programmes and the Japan Development Bank. The Ministry of Finance kept interest rates low so firms could borrow cheaply.
Protection gave young industries time to grow. Imports of cars and other goods were restricted until the 1960s, and foreign firms found it hard to invest in Japan.
In 1960 Prime Minister Ikeda launched the Income Doubling Plan. It set a target for the whole economy.
Policy did not always succeed. In the early 1960s MITI wanted to limit the number of car makers. Honda went ahead anyway and became a major car maker.
- MITI
- Created 1949; led industrial policy.
- Income Doubling Plan
- 1960: double national output in ten years; reached years early.
- Administrative guidance
- Informal advice that firms usually followed.
Real examples to use
Japan Development Bank, 1951
A state bank lent cheaply to priority industries such as steel, power and shipbuilding.
Sony's licence, 1953
MITI at first delayed Sony's request to buy foreign currency for transistor technology, which shows how much power officials had over firms.
Japan joins the OECD, 1964
Joining the rich countries' club meant opening the economy to more trade and investment, a limit on state protection.
Worked example: The Income Doubling Plan, 27 December 1960
On 27 December 1960 Ikeda's cabinet approved a plan to double Japan's output within ten years. It aimed to raise living standards and reach full employment.
- Target: output of 26 trillion yen, at 1958 prices, with growth of 9 per cent a year in the first three years.
- Tools: public spending on roads and ports, and cheap loans to chosen industries.
- Result: real growth averaged almost 10 per cent a year from 1961 to 1967, so the target was reached years early.
- Judgement: the state set goals and steered money, and that built confidence. But private firms and savers did much of the work.
Watch out for this
MITI planned the whole economy like a communist state.
Japan stayed a market economy. MITI guided private firms through incentives and advice, and firms competed fiercely with each other.
Check your understanding
How did the state steer savings into industry?
- It borrowed heavily from American and European banks.
- Postal savings were lent through government programmes to priority industries.
- It took private savings by law and spent them itself.
Show the answer
Postal savings were lent through government programmes to priority industries.
Right. Cheap credit flowed to chosen sectors.
Check your understanding
The Income Doubling Plan's target was reached years early. What does this suggest about the state's role?
- The plan failed, because growth was slower than the target.
- The state ran every factory, so it could meet any target it set.
- The state set goals, but private firms and savers did much of the work.
Show the answer
The state set goals, but private firms and savers did much of the work.
Right. The plan guided growth; it did not produce it alone.