Weighing the factors over time

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge which factors did most to transform the economies of Japan and China over time.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors that contributed to the economic transformation of Japan and China over time

Make a guess

Government, business groups, society and the world economy all helped Japan grow. Do you think one factor explains its growth from 1947 to 1991?

  1. No, American aid and military orders explain most of it.
  2. Yes, government planning by MITI explains it.
  3. No, the factors worked together, and their weight shifted.
Show the answer

No, the factors worked together, and their weight shifted.

International help led early recovery, all four drove high growth, and outside shocks shaped later decades.

Government, keiretsu, society and the world economy worked together, but their importance shifted between periods.

1947 to 1955: recovery owed most to international developments, through occupation reforms, the Dodge Line and the Korean War boom.

1955 to 1973: high growth came from all four factors together. Government chose industries, keiretsu banks lent them household savings, workers moved into factories, and the world economy was open and stable.

1973 to 1985: growth slowed to about 4 per cent a year. Firms and workers adapted to the oil crises, while the state's direct control declined.

1985 to 1991: international pressure and government decisions combined to create the bubble and its collapse.

Historians debate the role of the state. Chalmers Johnson called Japan a "developmental state" led by MITI. Others stress market competition and private firms. A strong essay shows how the factors depended on each other.

High growth
1955-1973, about 9 per cent a year.
Stable growth
1973-1990, about 4 per cent a year.
Debate
Developmental state versus market forces.

Real examples to use

Chalmers Johnson, 1982

MITI and the Japanese Miracle made the case for the developmental state: officials, not just markets, drove growth.

The lost decade, 1990s

Slow growth after the bubble burst weakened the claim that Japan's system could not fail.

Worked example: Japan's growth by period, 1956-1992

Cabinet Office figures for real growth, by fiscal year, show how the pace changed as the balance of factors shifted.

  1. High growth, 1956-1973: about 9 per cent a year, when all four factors pulled together.
  2. Stable growth, 1974-1985: about 4 per cent a year, after output fell in 1974 for the first time since the war.
  3. Bubble, 1986-1990: about 5 per cent a year, then 2.5 per cent in 1991 and 0.6 per cent in 1992.
  4. Judgement: the fastest growth came when the factors worked together. Each slowdown followed an outside shock or a policy choice.

Watch out for this

One factor explains Japan's growth from 1947 to 1991.

The balance changed. International help mattered most in recovery, domestic factors in high growth, and international pressure again after 1985.

Check your understanding

Which period saw Japan's fastest growth?

  1. 1955-1973
  2. 1986-1991
  3. 1973-1985
Show the answer

1955-1973

Right. Growth averaged about 9 per cent a year.

Check your understanding

An essay argues that Japan's officials, more than markets, chose which industries grew. Which side of the historians' debate does it support?

  1. Johnson's view of a developmental state
  2. The view that American aid drove growth
  3. The view that market competition drove growth
Show the answer

Johnson's view of a developmental state

Right. Chalmers Johnson argued that the state, through MITI, led Japan's growth.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready