What this lesson teaches
I can judge which causes mattered most in ending the Cold War, and weigh historians' views.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes of the end of the Cold War
Make a guess
In 1986 world oil prices collapsed. What do you think this did to the Soviet Union?
- Little, because a planned economy ignores world prices.
- It lost much of its foreign currency income.
- It gained, because cheaper oil cut its factories' costs.
Show the answer
It lost much of its foreign currency income.
Oil sales paid for imports, including grain and technology. The price crash deepened an economy already stagnating.
Economic stagnation, falling oil prices, the war in Afghanistan and military costs left the USSR unable to sustain the Cold War.
The Soviet planned economy stagnated from the 1970s. Factories met output targets but made poor goods. Shortages of food and consumer goods were common. The USSR fell further behind the West in technology, especially computers.
Military spending took a very large share of the economy, perhaps 15 to 25 per cent of output. Money spent on arms could not go to better goods or higher living standards. The USSR also paid to support allies in Eastern Europe, Cuba and Vietnam.
The war in Afghanistan, from 1979, cost lives and money without victory. When world oil prices collapsed in 1986, the USSR lost much of its foreign currency income.
The Chernobyl disaster of April 1986 showed how secret and wasteful the system was. These problems convinced Gorbachev that reform at home needed calm relations abroad.
- Afghanistan
- Soviet war from 1979.
- Oil price collapse
- 1986.
- Chernobyl
- April 1986.
Real examples to use
Afghanistan, 1979 to 1989
Nearly 15,000 Soviet soldiers died in a war the USSR could not win.
Oil earnings fall, 1985 to 1986
The CIA estimated that Soviet earnings from oil sales to the West fell about 20 per cent in 1985. The 1986 price collapse cut them further.
Worked example: Chernobyl, 26 April to 14 May 1986
A reactor at Chernobyl, in Soviet Ukraine, exploded on 26 April 1986. Soviet TV first reported it on 28 April, after Sweden had picked up the radiation. Gorbachev spoke to the nation only on 14 May. In the same speech he extended the Soviet halt on nuclear tests to 6 August and repeated his offer to meet Reagan.
- Secrecy: the system's first move was to hide the disaster.
- Cost: the clean-up was a heavy burden for an economy that was already stagnating.
- Link: Gorbachev used the disaster to argue for less nuclear danger and calmer relations.
- Use: this links decline at home to the search for calm abroad.
Watch out for this
The Soviet Union collapsed only because the USA outspent it.
US pressure added to the strain, but long-term economic weakness, Afghanistan and falling oil prices were also major causes.
Check your understanding
Why did the 1986 collapse in oil prices hurt the USSR?
- It forced the USSR to end aid to Cuba that year.
- Oil exports were a major source of its foreign currency.
- It had to import more oil for its factories.
Show the answer
Oil exports were a major source of its foreign currency.
Right. Lower earnings worsened its economic crisis.
Check your understanding
Military spending took perhaps 15 to 25 per cent of Soviet output. Why did this make reform harder?
- Soldiers ran the factories, so nothing could be made without them.
- Money spent on arms could not go to better goods and living standards.
- It meant the USSR was already ahead of the USA in technology.
Show the answer
Money spent on arms could not go to better goods and living standards.
Yes. So Gorbachev came to see that reform at home needed calm abroad and lower arms spending.