What this lesson teaches
I can judge which causes mattered most in ending the Cold War, and weigh historians' views.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes of the end of the Cold War
Make a guess
On 9 November 1989 the Berlin Wall opened. How do you think it happened?
- Soviet troops pulled down the Wall on Gorbachev's orders.
- A muddled travel announcement led crowds to force the crossings open.
- The East German government planned and held a careful opening ceremony.
Show the answer
A muddled travel announcement led crowds to force the crossings open.
Guards faced huge crowds and no clear orders, so they opened the gates. It was not a planned decision.
In Poland negotiation brought a non-communist government; in East Germany mass emigration and protest opened the Berlin Wall.
In Poland, the Solidarity trade union was formed in 1980 after strikes at the Gdansk shipyard. The government imposed martial law in December 1981 and banned it, but could not destroy it. By the late 1980s, economic crisis forced the communists to negotiate.
The Round Table talks ran from February to April 1989. They made Solidarity legal again and allowed partly free elections in June. Solidarity won almost every seat it could contest. In August 1989, Tadeusz Mazowiecki became the first non-communist prime minister in the Soviet bloc.
In East Germany, the trigger was escape. Hungary opened its border with Austria in 1989, and thousands of East Germans fled west. At home, crowds in Leipzig marched every Monday, chanting "We are the people". On 9 October 1989, about 70,000 marched and the security forces did not shoot.
The East German leader, Erich Honecker, was removed in October. On 9 November 1989 the Berlin Wall opened. Germany was united again on 3 October 1990. The Soviet Union itself broke up in December 1991.
Put these in order
Put these steps in East Germany's revolution in order.
- Crowds force the guards to open the Berlin Wall.
- About 70,000 march in Leipzig and the security forces do not shoot.
- Germany is reunified.
- Erich Honecker is removed as East German leader.
- Hungary opens its border with Austria to East Germans, and thousands flee west.
Show the answer
- Hungary opens its border with Austria to East Germans, and thousands flee west. September 1989: The flight showed how weak the regime was and spurred those who stayed to demand change at home.
- About 70,000 march in Leipzig and the security forces do not shoot. 9 October 1989: Once force was not used, protests grew, and the ruling party removed its hardline leader to try to calm them.
- Erich Honecker is removed as East German leader. October 1989: His successors tried to calm protest by easing travel rules, and a confused announcement sent crowds to the border.
- Crowds force the guards to open the Berlin Wall. 9 November 1989: With the border open, the East German regime collapsed, and voters there backed joining the Federal Republic. Germany was reunified on 3 October 1990.
- Germany is reunified.
- Solidarity
- Formed 1980; martial law December 1981.
- Polish elections
- June 1989; Mazowiecki prime minister in August.
- Berlin Wall opened
- 9 November 1989.
Real examples to use
Polish elections, 4 and 18 June 1989
Solidarity won all 161 freely contested seats in the Sejm and 99 of the 100 seats in the new Senate.
Hungary opens the border, 11 September 1989
Hungary let East Germans cross freely into Austria. About 36,000 had crossed that way by mid-October.
Honecker goes, 18 October 1989
The party replaced him with Egon Krenz, who promised change but could not stop the protests.
Worked example: A press conference opens the Wall, 9 November 1989
On the evening of 9 November 1989, a party leader, Gunter Schabowski, read out new travel rules at a press conference shown live on TV. A reporter asked when they took effect. He answered: "As far as I know, it takes effect immediately, without delay." Thousands of East Berliners went to the crossings. Late that night, at Bornholmer Strasse, the officer in charge gave in and opened the gate.
- People power: crowds turned a muddled statement into an open border.
- Regime weakness: the leaders had lost control of their own announcement.
- Moscow: no Soviet troops moved to close the border again.
- Compare: Poland's change was negotiated at a table, but East Germany's came from the street.
Watch out for this
The Berlin Wall was opened by a planned decision of the East German government.
The announcement about travel was confused and premature. Crowds gathered and forced border guards to open the crossings that night.
Check your understanding
What did the Polish Round Table talks of 1989 achieve?
- They legalised Solidarity and allowed partly free elections.
- They reunified Poland and East Germany.
- They brought Soviet troops into Poland to keep order.
Show the answer
They legalised Solidarity and allowed partly free elections.
Right. Solidarity's victory followed in June 1989.