What this lesson teaches
I can judge which causes mattered most in ending the Cold War, and weigh historians' views.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes of the end of the Cold War
Make a guess
Reagan called the USSR an "evil empire" in 1983. What do you think he and Gorbachev signed in December 1987?
- A treaty scrapping a whole class of nuclear missiles.
- A treaty to scrap the nuclear weapons of both sides by 2000.
- No treaty, because Reagan refused to negotiate with Soviet leaders.
Show the answer
A treaty scrapping a whole class of nuclear missiles.
The INF Treaty eliminated intermediate-range missiles and allowed on-site inspections, which built trust.
Reagan combined pressure with negotiation, and with Gorbachev reached the INF Treaty in 1987, the first to eliminate a class of nuclear weapons.
Reagan was not only a hawk. He believed nuclear weapons should be cut and even abolished. He was willing to negotiate from strength.
Gorbachev came to power in 1985, and the two leaders met at Geneva that November. At Reykjavik in October 1986 they came close to agreeing to abolish all nuclear weapons. Talks broke down because Reagan refused to limit SDI.
In December 1987 they signed the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces (INF) Treaty. It removed a whole class of missiles. It also allowed on-site inspections, which built trust. The START I treaty to cut long-range weapons was signed in July 1991.
Historians debate who deserves the credit. Some stress Reagan's strength, which made the USSR negotiate. Others stress that Gorbachev made most of the concessions.
- Reykjavik
- October 1986: near agreement; SDI the obstacle.
- INF Treaty
- December 1987: eliminates intermediate-range missiles.
- START I
- July 1991.
Real examples to use
Reykjavik, 11 to 12 October 1986
Reagan and Gorbachev discussed scrapping all nuclear weapons, but no deal was reached because Reagan would not limit SDI.
INF Treaty, 8 December 1987
By June 1991 the USA had destroyed 846 missiles and the USSR 1,846, a total of 2,692. It was the first treaty to cut nuclear weapons rather than cap them.
START I, 31 July 1991
Bush and Gorbachev agreed to limit each side to 6,000 long-range warheads on 1,600 missiles and bombers.
Worked example: Gorbachev unties the package, 28 February 1987
At Reykjavik, Gorbachev had tied every cut to limits on SDI. On 28 February 1987, he announced that a treaty on intermediate-range missiles no longer had to wait for other arms talks. That opened the way to the "zero option" Reagan had first proposed in 1981: removing all such missiles. Reagan welcomed the move, and the INF Treaty was signed on 8 December 1987.
- Soviet initiative: the decisive move came from Moscow, which gave up its main condition.
- Reagan's strength: the zero option was Reagan's own idea, and he kept SDI.
- Cross-reference: Reykjavik failed over SDI, but once Gorbachev untied it, a deal came within a year.
- Judgement: agreement needed both a firm Reagan and a reforming Gorbachev.
Watch out for this
The INF Treaty ended the nuclear arms race.
It eliminated intermediate-range missiles only. Strategic weapons remained, and START I came later, in 1991.
Check your understanding
Why did the Reykjavik summit fail to reach a full agreement?
- Gorbachev refused to discuss nuclear weapons.
- Reagan refused to limit SDI.
- The summit was cancelled.
Show the answer
Reagan refused to limit SDI.
Right. SDI was the sticking point.
Check your understanding
The INF Treaty let each side inspect the other's missile sites. Why did this matter?
- Each side could check the cuts for itself, which built trust.
- Inspectors could station NATO troops inside the Soviet Union.
- The treaty covered all nuclear weapons, so checks had to be wide.
Show the answer
Each side could check the cuts for itself, which built trust.
Yes. Seeing missiles destroyed made later agreements, such as START I, easier.