What this lesson teaches
I can judge how China's and Japan's relations with the USA and the USSR changed during the Cold War.
Syllabus 8838, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the development of China's and Japan's relations with the superpowers during the Cold War
Make a guess
The US occupation of Japan began in 1945 by disarming it and breaking up big businesses. How do you think US aims changed by 1948?
- They shifted to rebuilding Japan as a strong anti-communist ally.
- They became harsher, aiming to keep Japan poor.
- They ended, and US forces left Japan by 1948.
Show the answer
They shifted to rebuilding Japan as a strong anti-communist ally.
This reverse course put recovery ahead of reform, especially once China turned communist in 1949.
The Cold War turned the US occupation of Japan from reform to recovery, and ended with a peace treaty and a security treaty in 1951.
After 1945, the USA occupied Japan under General Douglas MacArthur. It disarmed the country, broke up big business groups and wrote a new constitution. Article 9 gave up war, and the right to keep armed forces for war.
As the Cold War deepened, US policy changed in 1947-48. This "reverse course" put economic recovery and stability ahead of reform. The USA now wanted a strong, non-communist Japan as an ally in Asia, especially after China became communist in 1949.
In September 1951, Japan signed the San Francisco Peace Treaty with most of its former enemies. The occupation ended in April 1952. The USSR refused to sign, and neither Chinese government was invited.
On the same day, Japan signed a Security Treaty with the USA. US forces could stay in Japan and use bases there. But the treaty did not clearly bind the USA to defend Japan. Many Japanese saw it as unequal.
- Article 9
- Japan renounces war and armed forces for war.
- Reverse course
- 1947-48: recovery over reform.
- 8 September 1951
- Peace treaty and Security Treaty signed; occupation ends April 1952.
Real examples to use
Article 9, in force 3 May 1947
Japan's new constitution gave up war and armed forces for war. It was written while the US aim was still reform.
San Francisco, 8 September 1951
Japan signed peace with 48 nations. The USSR refused to sign, and neither Chinese government was invited. The occupation ended on 28 April 1952.
Security Treaty, 8 September 1951
Signed the same day. US forces could stay in Japan, and at Japan's request could even help put down "large-scale internal riots and disturbances". No article bound the USA to defend Japan.
Worked example: Recovery first: NSC 13/2, October 1948
On 9 October 1948, Truman approved NSC 13/2, a new US policy for Japan. Second only to US security, it said, "economic recovery should be made the primary objective" there. The occupation should press no "further reform legislation" on Japan's government. The purge of wartime leaders would not be extended.
- Cold War: as communists advanced in China, the USA wanted Japan strong and on its side.
- Recovery: rebuilding Japan's economy now came before reform.
- Reform slowed: no new reform laws, and no wider purge.
- Result: by 1951 the new aim led to a peace treaty and an alliance.
Watch out for this
Japan became a fully equal ally of the USA in 1952.
The 1951 Security Treaty allowed US bases but did not clearly commit the USA to defend Japan. Many Japanese saw it as unequal, which fuelled later disputes.
Check your understanding
Why did the USA shift to the "reverse course" in Japan?
- The UN ordered the change after the Korean War began.
- Japan had elected a communist-led government in 1947.
- It wanted a strong, stable Japan as a Cold War ally.
Show the answer
It wanted a strong, stable Japan as a Cold War ally.
Right. Recovery replaced reform as the priority.
Check your understanding
Why did many Japanese see the 1951 Security Treaty as unequal?
- It placed Japan's new army under the command of the United Nations.
- It forced Japan to send its own troops to fight in the Korean War.
- US forces could use bases in Japan, but the USA was not bound to defend it.
Show the answer
US forces could use bases in Japan, but the USA was not bound to defend it.
Yes. Japan gave bases without a firm promise of defence in return.