Sharing the defence burden

H1 History - syllabus 8838, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how China's and Japan's relations with the USA and the USSR changed during the Cold War.

    Syllabus 8838, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the development of China's and Japan's relations with the superpowers during the Cold War

Make a guess

As Japan grew rich, Americans complained it got security without paying for it. What do you think Japan spent on defence?

  1. About 1 per cent of its GNP, a ceiling set in 1976.
  2. It kept no armed forces of its own, so US troops defended it.
  3. As much as the USA, measured as a share of income.
Show the answer

About 1 per cent of its GNP, a ceiling set in 1976.

Japan moved slowly. From 1978 it paid a growing share of US base costs, but it kept its own spending low.

The USA pressed Japan to do more for its own defence; Japan moved slowly, spending about 1 per cent of GNP until the late 1980s.

As Japan grew rich, Americans complained that it enjoyed security without paying for it. In 1969 the Nixon Doctrine asked Asian allies to do more for their own defence. US pressure for burden sharing grew through the 1970s.

Japan held defence spending to about 1 per cent of its gross national product (GNP), the value of all it produced. A cabinet decision in 1976 made this a formal ceiling. From 1978, Japan paid a growing share of the cost of US bases. This is called host-nation support.

In the 1980s, Soviet forces in the Pacific grew. Prime Minister Nakasone drew closer to the USA. In 1983 he was reported as calling Japan an "unsinkable aircraft carrier" against Soviet bombers. Japan built up its role in guarding sea lanes up to 1,000 nautical miles, a pledge first made in 1981. In 1987 the 1 per cent ceiling was broken.

Even so, Japan avoided a combat role abroad. The alliance became closer, but Japan's part stayed mainly financial and defensive.

1 per cent ceiling
Defence spending capped at about 1 per cent of GNP from 1976; breached 1987.
Host-nation support
Japan pays part of US base costs from 1978.
Nakasone
Prime minister 1982-87: closer defence ties.

Real examples to use

The 1 per cent ceiling, 1976 to 1987

A 1976 cabinet decision capped defence at 1 per cent of GNP. The 1987 budget broke it, at 1.004 per cent of expected GNP.

Nakasone in Washington, January 1983

A Washington Post interview reported Nakasone calling Japan an "unsinkable aircraft carrier" against Soviet bombers. That English wording was later said to be a mistranslation.

Sea-lane defence, 1981

Under Prime Minister Suzuki, Japan pledged to help guard sea lanes up to 1,000 nautical miles from its coast. It was a defensive task, not combat abroad.

Worked example: The defence guidelines, 27 November 1978

On 27 November 1978, Japanese and US officials approved the first Guidelines for Japan-U.S. Defense Cooperation. "In principle, Japan by itself will repel limited, small-scale aggression." Against a larger attack, Japan would fight "with the cooperation of the United States". The two forces would study joint defence planning, including guarding sea lanes.

  1. Burden: Japan took on the first line of its own defence, as Washington wanted.
  2. Cooperation: joint planning made the alliance work in practice, not just on paper.
  3. Limits: the roles stayed defensive and close to Japan, as Article 9 required.
  4. Judgement: Japan shared more of the burden, but on its own defensive terms.

Watch out for this

Japan refused to contribute anything to its defence alliance with the USA.

Japan spent about 1 per cent of GNP on defence and paid a growing share of US base costs from 1978. It avoided only a combat role abroad.

Check your understanding

Nakasone was reported as calling Japan an "unsinkable aircraft carrier". What did he mean?

  1. Japan would serve as a barrier against Soviet forces in the Pacific.
  2. Japan would build aircraft carriers to attack the USSR in Siberia.
  3. Japan would leave the alliance and defend itself.
Show the answer

Japan would serve as a barrier against Soviet forces in the Pacific.

Right. It signalled closer defence cooperation with the USA.

Check your understanding

The 1978 guidelines said Japan would repel "limited, small-scale aggression" by itself. Why did this matter to Washington?

  1. Japan agreed to send troops to fight in other Asian countries.
  2. US forces would leave Japan once the guidelines took effect.
  3. Japan was taking on more of its own defence.
Show the answer

Japan was taking on more of its own defence.

Yes. It met US calls for burden sharing while staying defensive.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready