What this lesson teaches
I can judge how China and Japan responded as the Cold War changed.
Syllabus 8838, Theme II, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the responses of China and Japan to the development of the Cold War
Make a guess
Under US pressure, Japan recognised Taiwan in 1952. When do you think it set up relations with Beijing?
- In the 1950s, as soon as the occupation ended.
- Not until 1990, because it stayed loyal to Taiwan.
- In 1972, after Nixon's surprise opening to China.
Show the answer
In 1972, after Nixon's surprise opening to China.
Japan had kept trade going through semi-official channels. Nixon's move freed Tanaka to visit Beijing.
Japan followed the USA in recognising Taiwan, kept trade with the mainland, then normalised relations with Beijing in 1972 after the Nixon shock.
Under US pressure, Japan recognised the Nationalist government on Taiwan. It signed a treaty with Taiwan in 1952 and had no formal ties with the People's Republic.
Japan still wanted to trade with mainland China, so it kept politics and trade apart. A 1962 deal, the LT trade agreement, let trade go on through half-official links.
Nixon's surprise opening to China in 1971 freed Japan to act. Prime Minister Tanaka Kakuei visited Beijing in September 1972 and set up full relations. Japan ended official ties with Taiwan but kept trading with it.
In 1978 Japan and China signed a Treaty of Peace and Friendship. It opposed any power seeking to dominate the region. The USSR saw this as aimed at it. From 1979 Japan lent China large sums, which helped Deng's reforms. Quarrels over Japan's wartime past went on, such as the 1982 textbook row.
- Treaty with Taiwan
- 1952.
- Normalisation with China
- September 1972, under Tanaka.
- Treaty of Peace and Friendship
- 1978, with an anti-hegemony clause.
Real examples to use
Treaty with Taiwan, 1952
Under US pressure Japan made peace with the Nationalist government, not Beijing.
LT trade, 9 November 1962
It was named after the two men who signed it, Liao Chengzhi and Takasaki Tatsunosuke. It set up five years of trade with no formal ties.
Peace and Friendship Treaty, 12 August 1978
The two foreign ministers signed it in Beijing. Moscow read its clause against any power seeking hegemony as aimed at the USSR.
Worked example: The Joint Communique, 29 September 1972
Tanaka and Zhou Enlai signed a Joint Communique in Beijing on 29 September 1972. Japan recognised the People's Republic "as the sole legal Government of China". On Taiwan, Japan "fully understands and respects" Beijing's stand. Japan said it was keenly aware of its responsibility for the serious damage done in the war. China gave up its demand for war reparations.
- Political: once Nixon moved, Japan acted fast, setting up full relations seven years before the USA.
- Taiwan: Japan chose careful words, and it kept trading with Taiwan after official ties ended.
- Economic: with reparations dropped, the way was open for trade and later loans.
- Judgement: Japan followed the US lead on the big turn, but set its own pace and terms.
Watch out for this
Japan recognised the People's Republic of China in the 1950s.
Japan recognised Taiwan in 1952 and normalised relations with Beijing only in 1972, after Nixon's opening.
Check your understanding
What allowed Japan to normalise relations with China in 1972?
- China joined the US alliance system after splitting with the USSR.
- Taiwan asked Japan to switch recognition.
- Nixon's opening to China removed the main obstacle in Japan-USA relations.
Show the answer
Nixon's opening to China removed the main obstacle in Japan-USA relations.
Right. Japan could now act without defying the USA.
Check your understanding
Japan set up full relations with Beijing in 1972, seven years before the USA. What does this show about Japan's response?
- A UN vote forced Japan to switch its recognition to Beijing.
- Japan had broken with the USA and left their alliance.
- After Nixon moved, Japan acted fast for its own interests.
Show the answer
After Nixon moved, Japan acted fast for its own interests.
Yes. It followed the US turn, then moved faster for its own reasons.