The early years: managing disputes and ZOPFAN

H1 History - syllabus 8838, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how ASEAN responded to the Cold War in Southeast Asia, and why.

    Syllabus 8838, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate ASEAN's responses to the development of the Cold War in Southeast Asia

Make a guess

In 1968 the Philippines and Malaysia quarrelled over Sabah and broke off relations. How do you think ASEAN helped?

  1. It ruled that Sabah belonged to the Philippines.
  2. It sent peacekeeping troops to Sabah to keep the sides apart.
  3. Regular meetings kept the dispute from becoming a war.
Show the answer

Regular meetings kept the dispute from becoming a war.

ASEAN achieved little in economics early on, but it stopped quarrels between members from turning into fighting.

In its first years ASEAN achieved little in economics but helped stop quarrels, such as over Sabah, from becoming wars.

ASEAN's early years were slow. Its foreign ministers met about once a year, and its leaders did not hold a summit until 1976. It did little on trade. Its main success was stopping things from going wrong. Regular meetings kept quarrels between members from turning into fighting.

The Sabah dispute tested it. In 1968 the Philippines pressed its claim to Sabah, which was part of Malaysia. The two broke off relations, and ASEAN meetings were disrupted. The USA chose to stay out, so that ASEAN members would handle their own affairs. In December 1969, at an ASEAN meeting, the two agreed to restore relations.

In November 1971, ASEAN declared the aim of a Zone of Peace, Freedom and Neutrality (ZOPFAN). Neutral here means taking no side between the great powers. Members hoped to keep the great powers from meddling in the region. The timing mattered. The USA was cutting its role in Asia and opening ties with China.

During the Second Indochina War, ASEAN took no military role as a group. Its members acted differently. Thailand and the Philippines sent troops to help the USA in South Vietnam. Indonesia stayed non-aligned. ZOPFAN stayed a hope rather than a fact.

Sabah dispute
1968-69: ties broken, then restored at an ASEAN meeting.
ZOPFAN
Kuala Lumpur, 27 November 1971.
Neutrality
Taking no side between the great powers.

Real examples to use

Sabah quarrel, 1968 to 1969

In March 1968, the killing of trainees on Corregidor island exposed a Philippine plan to stir trouble in Sabah. Later that year the two states broke off relations. They met at an ASEAN meeting in the Cameron Highlands on 16-17 December 1969. There they agreed to restore ties "because of the great value Malaysia and the Philippines placed on ASEAN".

Security outside ASEAN, 1971

Malaysia and Singapore kept defence links with Britain, Australia and New Zealand through the Five Power Defence Arrangements of 1971.

Members in the Vietnam War

Thailand had about 11,600 troops in South Vietnam in 1969-70. The Philippines had about 2,000 there in 1966-67, in a civic action group.

Worked example: The ZOPFAN declaration, Kuala Lumpur, 27 November 1971

The five foreign ministers agreed that making Southeast Asia neutral was "a desirable objective". They would "explore ways and means" to bring it about. They promised "initially necessary efforts" to win respect for a zone "free from any form or manner of interference by outside Powers". The text set no deadline and no way to enforce it. American bases stayed in Thailand and the Philippines.

  1. Collectively: a shared aim, worded as something to explore, not a plan.
  2. Individually: Thailand and the Philippines kept close American ties, while Indonesia stayed non-aligned.
  3. Why: members wanted different things, and the USA was pulling back from Asia.
  4. Judgement: a cautious response that kept members together but changed little on the ground.

Watch out for this

ZOPFAN made Southeast Asia neutral in 1971.

ZOPFAN was a declared aim. Foreign bases and alliances remained, so the region did not become neutral.

Check your understanding

What did ZOPFAN aim to do?

  1. Keep Southeast Asia free from great-power interference
  2. Bring the region into the Warsaw Pact
  3. Create an ASEAN army to defend the region
Show the answer

Keep Southeast Asia free from great-power interference

Right. It was declared in November 1971.

Check your understanding

In 1971 ASEAN said it would "explore ways and means" to make the region neutral. What does this wording show?

  1. The region had already become neutral, so nothing more was needed.
  2. The great powers had already promised to guarantee the zone's neutrality.
  3. Members agreed on the goal but not on how to reach it.
Show the answer

Members agreed on the goal but not on how to reach it.

Yes. ZOPFAN set no deadline and no way to enforce it, because members' needs differed.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

  • The USA stays out of the Sabah dispute

    Paraphrase of an action memorandum from Assistant Secretary of State William Bundy to Secretary of State Rusk, 20 May 1968.

  • A CIA assessment of ASEAN

    Paraphrase of a CIA paper, "Regionalism in Southeast Asia: The Growth of ASEAN", 1 January 1981.

  • The USA should consult ASEAN

    Paraphrase of a memorandum from the Director of the State Department's Office of Regional Affairs, East Asia, 31 January 1977.

  • Thailand considers an ASEAN response

    Paraphrase of a telegram from the US embassy in Bangkok to the State Department, 4 January 1979.

  • Lee Kuan Yew on ASEAN's position

    Paraphrase of a letter from Singapore's Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew to President Carter, 1 March 1979.

  • the founding aims, 1967

    Paraphrase of the ASEAN Declaration (Bangkok Declaration), signed by the foreign ministers of Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore and Thailand, 8 August 1967.

  • the leaders report progress, 1977

    Paraphrase of the Joint Communique of the Second ASEAN Heads of Government Meeting, Kuala Lumpur, 5 August 1977.

  • an American intelligence assessment, 1981

    Extract from "Regionalism in Southeast Asia: The Growth of ASEAN", a research paper by the CIA's National Foreign Assessment Center, 1 January 1981, published in Foreign Relations of the United States, 1977-1980, volume XXII, document 149. A US government document in the public domain.

  • a free trade area, 1992

    Paraphrase of the preamble and Article 2 of the Framework Agreement on Enhancing ASEAN Economic Cooperation, adopted by the six ASEAN heads of government at the Fourth ASEAN Summit, Singapore, 28 January 1992.

  • bold measures after the crisis, 1998

    Paraphrase of the Statement on Bold Measures, issued by ASEAN leaders at the Sixth ASEAN Summit, Hanoi, 16 December 1998.

  • Vietnam joins ASEAN, 1995

    Extract from the Joint Communique of the 28th ASEAN Ministerial Meeting, Bandar Seri Begawan, 29-30 July 1995, paragraph 2, as circulated by Brunei Darussalam to the United Nations General Assembly and Security Council (UN document A/49/953-S/1995/652).

  • ASEAN welcomes Laos and Myanmar, 1997

    Paraphrase of paragraph 2 of the Joint Communique of the 30th ASEAN Ministerial Meeting, Subang Jaya, Malaysia, 24-25 July 1997.

  • the American Secretary of State on Burma, 1997

    Extract from an address by US Secretary of State Madeleine Albright to the Pacific Council on International Policy and the Los Angeles World Affairs Council, Los Angeles, 23 July 1997, the day before she left for the ASEAN meetings in Kuala Lumpur. Released by the State Department, 24 July 1997. A US government document in the public domain.

  • Cambodia must wait, 1997

    Paraphrase of paragraph 15 of the Joint Communique of the 30th ASEAN Ministerial Meeting, Subang Jaya, Malaysia, 24-25 July 1997, written after fighting in Phnom Penh between the forces of Cambodia's two co-prime ministers in early July.

  • narrowing the gap, 2000

    Paraphrase of the Chairman's Statement of the Fourth ASEAN Informal Summit, Singapore, 24 November 2000, on the Initiative for ASEAN Integration.

  • a cartoon about expansion, 1997

    An original cartoon drawn for these notes in the style of a regional newspaper cartoon published in late July 1997, after ASEAN admitted Laos and Myanmar and postponed Cambodia's entry. It is not a copy of a real cartoon. The words of the figure at the window echo Source C.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready