What this lesson teaches
I can judge how ASEAN responded to the Cold War in Southeast Asia, and why.
Syllabus 8838, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate ASEAN's responses to the development of the Cold War in Southeast Asia
Make a guess
Vietnam invaded Cambodia in December 1978. How do you think ASEAN responded?
- It accepted the new government as legitimate.
- It led a diplomatic campaign at the UN against the occupation.
- It sent an army to drive Vietnam out of Cambodia.
Show the answer
It led a diplomatic campaign at the UN against the occupation.
ASEAN condemned the use of force and kept Cambodia's UN seat away from the Vietnamese-backed government.
ASEAN led the diplomatic campaign against Vietnam's occupation of Cambodia, which was its greatest Cold War success, though members differed.
Vietnam invaded Cambodia in December 1978. ASEAN condemned the use of force against a sovereign state. Thailand became a frontline state. It had Vietnamese troops on its border and hundreds of thousands of refugees.
ASEAN led a yearly campaign at the United Nations. Each year it asked for foreign forces to leave Cambodia. It pressed for the UN's International Conference on Kampuchea, held in July 1981. In 1982 it helped form the Coalition Government of Democratic Kampuchea (CGDK). This coalition kept Cambodia's UN seat out of the hands of the Vietnamese-backed government.
Members did not fully agree. Thailand and Singapore took a hard line against Vietnam. Indonesia and Malaysia saw China as the greater long-term threat, as their 1980 Kuantan Principle showed. ASEAN kept its unity by compromise.
From 1988 Indonesia hosted the Jakarta Informal Meetings, which brought the Cambodian parties together. The final deal, the Paris Agreements of 1991, came after the great powers changed course. But ASEAN had kept the issue alive and shaped the terms.
- UN campaign
- Yearly resolutions calling for withdrawal, from 1979.
- CGDK
- 1982.
- Jakarta Informal Meetings
- 1988 and 1989.
Real examples to use
Coalition formed, Kuala Lumpur, 22 June 1982
Sihanouk, Son Sann and the Khmer Rouge's Khieu Samphan signed a declaration forming the CGDK. It held Cambodia's UN seat through the 1980s.
Kuantan, March 1980
Suharto and Malaysia's Hussein Onn met at Kuantan. They called for a Vietnam free of both Soviet and Chinese influence, which showed members did not see the threat the same way.
Jakarta Informal Meeting, July 1988
At Bogor, Indonesia brought all four Cambodian parties and Vietnam together for the first time. The talks led on to the Paris Agreements of 23 October 1991.
Worked example: The UN vote on Kampuchea, 14 November 1979
A resolution led by ASEAN passed the UN General Assembly by 91 votes to 21, with 29 abstentions. It called for "the immediate withdrawal of all foreign forces from Kampuchea". It asked all states to "refrain from any interference in the internal affairs of Kampuchea". The USA and China voted for it. The USSR and Vietnam voted against. Vietnamese troops stayed in Cambodia until 1989.
- Success: a large majority backed ASEAN's line and left Vietnam isolated.
- Success: five small states led world opinion by acting as one bloc.
- Limit: a vote could not move troops; Chinese and American pressure counted for more.
- Judgement: strong in diplomacy, weak at changing events on the ground.
Watch out for this
ASEAN fought a war to remove Vietnam from Cambodia.
ASEAN used diplomacy, not force. Its tools were UN votes, conferences and support for a resistance coalition.
Check your understanding
What was the Kuantan Principle of 1980?
- A plan for an ASEAN army to drive Vietnamese forces out of Cambodia
- An agreement to admit Vietnam into ASEAN once it left Cambodia
- A sign that Indonesia and Malaysia saw China as the bigger long-term threat
Show the answer
A sign that Indonesia and Malaysia saw China as the bigger long-term threat
Right. It showed differences within ASEAN.
Check your understanding
ASEAN's UN resolution of November 1979 passed by 91 votes to 21. What did it fail to do?
- Win a majority in the General Assembly.
- Win China's support.
- Get Vietnamese troops out of Cambodia.
Show the answer
Get Vietnamese troops out of Cambodia.
Yes. A UN vote could not move troops, and Vietnam stayed until 1989.