What this lesson teaches
I can judge how ASEAN responded to the Cold War in Southeast Asia, and why.
Syllabus 8838, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate ASEAN's responses to the development of the Cold War in Southeast Asia
Make a guess
ASEAN members decide only when all agree, and do not criticise each other in public. What do you think this achieved?
- Very little, because members could rarely agree on anything.
- Peace between members, but limits on what ASEAN could do.
- Fast, bold decisions on each regional problem.
Show the answer
Peace between members, but limits on what ASEAN could do.
No two members went to war during the Cold War, but consensus slowed action and avoided hard issues.
Consensus and non-interference kept ASEAN united and members at peace, but limited what it could achieve.
The ASEAN Way is ASEAN's style of working. Members decide only when all agree, which is called consensus. They avoid criticising each other in public. And they do not meddle in each other's internal affairs. This suited young, varied states that guarded their independence.
Its success was stability. No two ASEAN members went to war with each other during the Cold War, though several had serious quarrels. Regular meetings built trust among leaders.
Its weakness was doing too little. A CIA paper of January 1981 found that consensus had "enhanced unity but resulted in inaction in some areas". Economic plans achieved little, because each state put its own interests first.
ASEAN also depended on outside powers. Members rejected a shared defence pact. They relied on the USA and others for security, while trying not to look too close to any superpower.
- ASEAN Way
- Consensus, quiet diplomacy, non-interference.
- No intra-ASEAN wars
- A key achievement during the Cold War.
- Security
- Members relied on outside powers, especially the USA.
Real examples to use
No war between members
Despite quarrels over Sabah, Cambodia policy and borders, no two ASEAN members fought a war with each other from 1967 to 1991.
Limits of the 1977 trade deal
The Preferential Trading Arrangement changed little. Each member protected its own industries, so many goods on the list were ones members hardly traded with each other.
American bases in the Philippines
Clark Air Base and Subic Bay naval base stayed in American hands until 1991 and 1992. Members spoke of a zone free of outside powers but still relied on them.
Worked example: Marcos and the Sabah claim, August 1977
At ASEAN's second summit, in Kuala Lumpur, President Marcos of the Philippines spoke about his country's claim to Sabah. He promised "definite steps to eliminate one of the burdens of ASEAN". The promise eased a quarrel that had strained ASEAN in 1968-69. But the Philippines never formally gave up the claim.
- Stability: a quarrel between members was calmed at an ASEAN meeting, not on a battlefield.
- ASEAN Way: a leader's promise handled the issue, not a ruling or a vote.
- Limit: the claim was set aside, not settled, so it could return.
- Judgement: the ASEAN Way kept the peace but left hard questions open.
Watch out for this
ASEAN's non-interference meant it did nothing.
Non-interference limited action inside members, but ASEAN acted effectively as a diplomatic bloc, as over Cambodia.
Check your understanding
What did a 1981 CIA assessment see as a weakness of ASEAN?
- ASEAN had grown too large to agree on policy.
- ASEAN was too ready to use force against its neighbours.
- Consensus decision-making led to inaction, especially in economics.
Show the answer
Consensus decision-making led to inaction, especially in economics.
Right. Unity came at a cost.
Check your understanding
In 1977 Marcos promised steps to drop the Philippine claim to Sabah, but the claim was never formally given up. What does this show about the ASEAN Way?
- Quarrels were calmed and set aside rather than settled.
- The Philippines left ASEAN until the claim was settled.
- ASEAN ruled on the claim and made the Philippines drop it.
Show the answer
Quarrels were calmed and set aside rather than settled.
Yes. Quiet diplomacy kept the peace but left the claim open.