What this lesson teaches
I can explain what an integration policy is and the tensions it can cause.
Syllabus K336, Issue 2, Guiding Question 3, Citizens and government responding to socio-cultural diversity. Integration policy and its tensions
Make a guess
Since 1989, HDB has limited how many people of each ethnic group can live in a block. Why do you think it does this?
- To keep people of different races living side by side.
- To make families in each block adopt one shared culture.
- To keep each ethnic group in its own separate estate.
Show the answer
To keep people of different races living side by side.
The Ethnic Integration Policy prevents enclaves. Daily contact in shared estates supports integration, though some owners find selling harder.
Integration builds a shared sense of belonging while letting people keep their own cultures.
Integration means people from different groups take part in society together while keeping their own identities. Singapore follows this approach.
The government can support a common language, shared schools and services, fair access and chances to work together. One example is bilingual education: students learn English as a common language, plus their mother tongue. Another is the Ethnic Integration Policy, started by HDB in 1989. It keeps a mix of ethnic groups in each HDB block and neighbourhood.
Integration needs effort from everyone. Individuals and groups build daily contact and joint activities. Newcomers learn about the wider society. Existing communities listen, include others and adapt where it makes sense.
Keeping cultural differences is only half of integration. If groups stay apart and share no common life, integration has not happened. Common rules for public life can sit alongside different languages, beliefs and practices. Including others also does not mean saying yes to every request.
Tensions can remain. People may disagree about shared rules, how space is used and what is fair. Accommodation means changing plans to suit different needs, such as meal choices or meeting times. Some residents may fear losing a way of life they know. Others may feel left out or pushed to fit in. These worries need facts and open talk. Calling a policy integration does not make harmony certain.
- Integration
- Shared participation and belonging, while keeping distinct cultures.
- Bilingual education
- English as the common language, plus mother tongue.
- Ethnic Integration Policy
- HDB rule (1989) keeping ethnic mixes in blocks and neighbourhoods.
Real examples to use
Ethnic Integration Policy
Since 1989, HDB has limited the share of each ethnic group in a block and neighbourhood. This way, people of all races live side by side. A tension: some owners find it harder to sell their flat.
Bilingual policy
Students learn English as a common language and their Mother Tongue to keep their heritage.
Tudung for nurses, 2021
From 1 November 2021, Muslim women in public healthcare could wear the tudung with their uniform. Use it to show shared rules that make room for a religious practice.
Worked example: The tudung with nurses' uniforms, from 2021
For years, Muslim nurses in public hospitals could not wear the tudung, a headscarf, with their uniform. On 29 August 2021, PM Lee Hsien Loong said this would change. From 1 November 2021, more than 7,000 Muslim women working in public healthcare could wear the tudung with their uniform.
- Shared institution: nurses still wear one uniform and follow the same rules at work.
- Room for identity: Muslim nurses can keep a religious practice while serving everyone. That is integration, not assimilation.
- Tension: one uniform for all has to be weighed against room for religious dress. The change covered public healthcare only, so the question can come up again in other jobs.
Watch out for this
Integration means making everyone the same, or leaving groups completely separate.
Integration is in between. People take part in shared life and feel they belong, while keeping their own cultures.
Check your understanding
How is integration different from assimilation?
- Integration is voluntary, while assimilation is what a government requires by law.
- Integration lets groups keep their cultures; assimilation asks them to drop them.
- Integration mixes groups in housing; assimilation mixes them in schools and at work.
Show the answer
Integration lets groups keep their cultures; assimilation asks them to drop them.
Right. That is the key difference.
Check your understanding
What is one tension created by the Ethnic Integration Policy?
- Ethnic groups end up in separate blocks because of the limits on each block.
- Residents are expected to give up some of their own customs to fit in with neighbours.
- Some owners find it harder to sell their flat to buyers from some ethnic groups, which limits their choice.
Show the answer
Some owners find it harder to sell their flat to buyers from some ethnic groups, which limits their choice.
The policy mixes neighbours, but limits some owners' choices.