What this lesson teaches
I can explain what an assimilationist policy is and the tensions it can cause.
Syllabus K336, Issue 2, Guiding Question 3, Citizens and government responding to socio-cultural diversity. Assimilationist policy and its tensions
Make a guess
In 2004, France banned conspicuous religious symbols, such as headscarves and turbans, in state schools. How do you think some minority students felt?
- Pleased, because students now looked more alike at school.
- Unaffected, because the law covered all religions equally.
- Excluded, as if accepted only by giving up their practices.
Show the answer
Excluded, as if accepted only by giving up their practices.
Assimilation seeks unity through sameness. Critics said the law excluded students whose religion was part of their identity.
An assimilationist policy expects minority groups to adopt the main culture and give up parts of their own.
Assimilation aims for unity through sameness. It expects minorities and newcomers to take on the main culture and set aside their own language or customs. The dominant culture is the one with the most influence. Norms are the expected ways of behaving.
The idea is that a shared language, shared practices and one public identity will build a common nation. Policies differ in how strongly they push people to change.
Tension comes over which practices count as common and what people must give up. Some see sameness as a source of unity. Others feel they are accepted only if they drop a valued language, custom or religious practice. Pressure to fit in can weaken belonging. Taking on the main culture also does not guarantee freedom from discrimination.
Look for a real push to replace or reduce cultural differences. A shared language lesson, or a common rule for public life called a civic rule, is not assimilation on its own. These also exist under integration. And one policy does not mean everyone in a country shares the same beliefs.
- Assimilation
- Expecting minorities to adopt the dominant culture and give up their own.
- Aim
- Unity through sameness.
- Risk
- People may feel excluded or pressured.
Real examples to use
France's 2004 law
France banned students in state schools from wearing obvious religious symbols, such as headscarves, Jewish skullcaps and large crosses. Sikh boys were expelled for wearing turbans. Supporters said it kept religion out of state schools. Critics said it shut out minorities. In the first school year, 47 pupils were expelled.
Chinese Indonesians, 1966 to 2000
Suharto's government urged Chinese Indonesians to take Indonesian-sounding names. It closed Chinese schools and kept Chinese festivals at home. The rules were lifted in 2000. Use it to show pressure on a minority to blend in.
Worked example: Chinese Indonesians under Suharto, 1966 to 2000
From 1966, Indonesia's leader, Suharto, pushed its Chinese minority to blend in with the majority. They were urged to take Indonesian-sounding names. Chinese-language schools were closed. From 1967, Chinese prayers and festivals had to be kept at home. In 2000, President Abdurrahman Wahid lifted that rule. Chinese New Year became a national holiday in 2003.
- Assimilation: the policy expected one minority to give up its names, language and public festivals.
- Tension: the government said sameness would build unity. But many Chinese Indonesians felt they had to hide who they were. New names did not protect them either: in May 1998, rioters attacked Chinese Indonesians.
- Change: later leaders lifted the rules. A push for sameness can be undone.
Watch out for this
Any policy with a common language is assimilation, and assimilation always brings harmony.
A shared language can exist alongside different cultures. Forcing sameness can cause tension, not harmony.
Check your understanding
Which policy is assimilationist?
- Celebrating each community's festivals at school with shared activities.
- Teaching students a common working language while keeping their mother tongues.
- Requiring newcomers to stop using their own language in public places.
Show the answer
Requiring newcomers to stop using their own language in public places.
Yes. It expects people to give up part of their identity.
Check your understanding
Under Suharto, Chinese Indonesians were urged to take Indonesian-sounding names. Why is this an assimilationist policy?
- It applied to every group in Indonesia equally, so no one had to change.
- It gave Chinese Indonesians a shared language while letting them keep their own.
- It expected a minority to give up part of its identity to fit the majority.
Show the answer
It expected a minority to give up part of its identity to fit the majority.
Right. Assimilation seeks unity through sameness, so minorities are pushed to drop what makes them different.