Stakeholders and decision-making

G3 Full Geography - syllabus K329, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how well stakeholders, with their different priorities and power, influence sustainable tourism.

    Syllabus K329, Topic 2.3, Key Question 2. How effective are stakeholders in influencing sustainable tourism development?

Make a guess

Residents are invited to a public meeting about a new hotel. Does this mean they have equal say with the developer?

  1. Yes, because everyone at the meeting can speak.
  2. Yes, because the government runs the meeting.
  3. No, because residents are not stakeholders.
  4. No. Power is still unequal.
Show the answer

No. Power is still unequal.

An invitation does not remove differences in power. Real participation means residents can change the decision and see how their views were used.

Stakeholders have different priorities and different amounts of power, and real participation means being able to change decisions.

Stakeholders are people or organisations affected by tourism or able to influence it. They have different roles and often disagree about what success looks like.

Governments make tourism plans, decide how land is used, and set and enforce rules. International groups, such as UN agencies, give advice, money and expert help, and make the public more aware. All of this needs money and staff who work together. Writing a plan is only the start.

Businesses choose their suppliers, the jobs they offer and what they sell. They also decide how much water, energy and material they use. Businesses and local communities can ask for advice and take part in decisions. Tourists shape demand through what they buy and how they behave. Visitors who learn about a place and respect its limits do less harm, but they need clear information and real choices.

Priorities can clash. A hotel may want more guests, residents may want a reliable water supply, and park managers may need fewer visitors at a fragile site. So each group may judge success by a different measure: profit, good jobs, control over its culture or the health of habitats.

Power is also unequal. Some stakeholders control more land, money or information, or have the final say. Inviting residents to a meeting does not change this. Real participation lets less-heard groups shape decisions, and shows them how their views were used.

Stakeholder
Anyone affected by, or able to influence, tourism.
Conflicting priorities
Profit, water, culture or conservation.
Real participation
Being able to change decisions, not just attend.

Step by step

Find the role

What can each group change or fund?

Compare power

Who controls land, money and decisions?

Check results

Look for action and results, not just plans.

Real examples to use

Venice and cruise ships

Residents campaigned for years against large cruise ships sailing past the city centre. In 2021, Italy banned the largest ships from the central Giudecca Canal.

Worked example: Angkor's planning

UNESCO describes how Angkor's 2012-2020 tourism plan consulted businesses, communities, monks and charities. A lived-in heritage site needs many voices. The plan shows a process, not proof every problem was solved.

    Watch out for this

    Everyone on the invitation list has equal power.

    Money, time, information and authority still differ. Ask whether participation changed the decision.

    Check your understanding

    What best shows real community participation?

    1. Residents attend a meeting once the decisions have been made.
    2. Residents shape choices and hear how their views were used.
    3. The biggest investor defines success, since it carries the risk.
    Show the answer

    Residents shape choices and hear how their views were used.

    Yes. Their input changes the outcome.

    Check your understanding

    A hotel group calls a new resort a success because bookings doubled. The park manager calls it a failure because the reef was damaged. Why do they disagree?

    1. The hotel group has more money, so its view must be right.
    2. They judge success by different measures: bookings or reef health.
    3. One of them must be reading the figures wrongly.
    Show the answer

    They judge success by different measures: bookings or reef health.

    Yes. Both figures can be true. Stakeholders with different priorities measure success differently, so a judgement must weigh both.

    The Wise Otter

    Getting your study space ready