Fair benefits and trade-offs

G3 Full Geography - syllabus K329, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can explain how responsible production and consumption can keep tourism sustainable in the future.

    Syllabus K329, Topic 2.3, Key Question 4. How might tourism continue to develop sustainably?

Make a guess

After a tourism boom, a town's average income goes up. Can some residents still be worse off?

  1. Yes. An average can hide people who lose out.
  2. Not unless the town has no hotels.
  3. No, because fair distribution means equal incomes.
  4. No, because a higher average means everyone gains.
Show the answer

Yes. An average can hide people who lose out.

A few high earners can lift the average while others face higher rents or lose business. Compare groups, not just the average.

Look beyond averages: compare who gains, who pays the costs and whether the benefits can last.

Fair distribution means sharing benefits and opportunities fairly across society. It does not mean everyone earns the same. It does mean checking who pays the costs or misses out. An average can hide big differences.

A trade-off is when one gain brings a cost somewhere else. Between dimensions, a new hotel may create jobs but use more water. Within one dimension, profits may rise while workers stay poorly paid or small firms lose business.

Fair buying, good working conditions, open shared funds and real participation can reduce these trade-offs. They cannot remove every cost.

Use several measures over time: job security, money kept locally, residents' access, cultural control, water use and habitat health. Compare groups and seasons. A good judgement explains which approach fits the destination, what evidence supports it and what is needed for benefits to last.

Fair distribution
Sharing benefits fairly, not equally.
Trade-off
A gain in one area brings a cost in another.
Averages
Can hide large differences between groups.

Step by step

Compare groups

Workers, owners, residents and poorer households.

Explain the trade-off

Link each gain to its cost.

Judge and review

Choose an approach and monitor results.

Real examples to use

Bali's water, 2012

The researcher Stroma Cole reported in 2012 that tourism used about 65% of Bali's water. Hotels gained from tourism. Some rice farmers faced conflicts over water, and some poorer residents' wells ran dry. The gains and the costs fell on different people.

Worked example: Most people can gain less than average

In made-up data, 10 owners each gain $1,000 a month and 90 workers each gain $20. The average gain is $118 per person, yet most people gain only $20. So check who gains, not just the average.

    Try it step by step

    Problem 1

    Made-up data: 10 owners each gain $1,000 a month from a new resort, and 90 workers each gain $20.

    Show the working
    1. Total gain: Total = 10 x $1,000 + 90 x $20 = $10,000 + $1,800 = $11,800.
    2. Mean per person: Mean = $11,800 / 100 people = $118 per person.
    3. Compare with most people: 90 of the 100 people gain only $20, far below the $118 mean. The average hides that most people gain little.

    Problem 2

    Made-up data: 5 guesthouse owners each gain $2,000 a month, and 45 helpers each gain $100. The first two steps are done for you.

    Show the working
    1. Total gain: Total = 5 x $2,000 + 45 x $100 = $10,000 + $4,500 = $14,500.
    2. Mean per person: Mean = $14,500 / 50 people = $290 per person.
    3. Compare with most people: 45 of the 50 people gain $100, about a third of the $290 mean. The average hides that most gain far less.

    Watch out for this

    A higher average income proves everyone benefits equally.

    An average hides the spread. Look at different groups.

    Check your understanding

    A tourism project reports higher average income. What is the best next step?

    1. Report the rise in income as proof that the project has succeeded.
    2. Examine gains, access and costs for each group over time.
    3. Assume a typical household gained about the average.
    Show the answer

    Examine gains, access and costs for each group over time.

    Yes. Averages hide differences.

    The Wise Otter

    Getting your study space ready