What this lesson teaches
I can weigh up how the returning European powers responded to demands for independence, by force or by talks.
Syllabus K330, Decolonisation and establishment of newly independent nations in Southeast Asia, Learning Outcomes. Assess the responses by the European powers to Southeast Asia's struggle for independence.
Make a guess
The Dutch and the Republic signed agreements in 1946 and 1948, yet fighting continued. Why do you think the deals did not hold?
- The UN ordered both sides to tear up the agreements.
- They still disagreed about who would hold power in the federation.
- The Republic already had full independence from 1945, so it ignored the deals.
Show the answer
They still disagreed about who would hold power in the federation.
The Dutch wanted to keep influence, and the Republic feared Dutch-backed states would weaken it. Each deal left this unsettled.
Agreements gave the Republic a seat at the table, but fighting went on because the two sides still disagreed about power.
The Linggadjati agreement of 1946 to 1947 recognised the Republic's de facto power in Java, Madura and Sumatra. De facto means the power it really held in practice. It was not full sovereignty over all of Indonesia. Madura is an island next to Java.
The plan was for the Republic and other states to join a federal United States of Indonesia. This new state would be linked to the Netherlands. In a federation, there is a national government, but the member states keep some powers.
But the two sides disputed who would hold power in the federation. The Dutch wanted to keep their influence. Republican leaders feared that states backed by the Dutch would weaken the Republic. So recognition was a real gain. But agreeing on a plan did not settle how free or strong the Republic would be.
After the Dutch attack of 1947, the Renville agreement of January 1948 set up a ceasefire, a halt to fighting, and more talks. Republican troops had to leave pockets of land behind Dutch lines. This weakened the Republic's hold on its land. The United Nations kept the talks going as a mediator, an outsider who helps two sides agree.
Neither agreement ended the war. Gains in battle changed what each side could demand in talks. Broken agreements and new Dutch attacks also turned world opinion against the Netherlands.
- Linggadjati, 1946-1947
- Recognises Republic's control of Java, Madura and Sumatra.
- Renville, January 1948
- Ceasefire; Republican troops withdraw from Dutch-held areas.
- UN
- Acted as mediator to keep talks going.
Real examples to use
Linggadjati, 1946 to 1947
The two sides agreed a draft on 15 November 1946 and signed it on 25 March 1947. On 20 July 1947 the Dutch abandoned it and attacked that night.
Renville, 17 January 1948
The agreement was signed on the USS Renville, an American ship in Jakarta Bay. A UN committee of Australia, Belgium and the USA had helped the two sides talk. In February, the Republic's Siliwangi Division marched out of West Java.
Worked example: A gain in recognition, a fight over power
At Linggadjati, the Republic is recognised in three islands and agrees to work towards a federation.
- Gain: the Dutch accept the Republic runs these islands.
- Problem: the two sides disagree about who holds power in the federation.
- Result: fighting starts again in 1947.
Watch out for this
Failed agreements did nothing to help independence.
Even broken deals gave the Republic recognition and kept talks open. Dutch attacks after them also turned world opinion against the Netherlands.
Check your understanding
What did the Linggadjati agreement give the Republic?
- Independence for the Republic over the whole archipelago.
- A lasting end to the fighting between the two sides.
- Recognition that it ran Java, Madura and Sumatra in practice.
Show the answer
Recognition that it ran Java, Madura and Sumatra in practice.
Yes. It was a real gain, even though the deal later broke down.
Check your understanding
Why was the Renville agreement of January 1948 a setback for the Republic?
- It ended the UN's part in the talks, leaving the Republic alone.
- It made the Republic give up its claim to independence.
- Its troops had to leave land behind Dutch lines, which weakened its hold.
Show the answer
Its troops had to leave land behind Dutch lines, which weakened its hold.
Yes. Republican troops left pockets behind Dutch lines, so the Republic held less land.