What this lesson teaches
I can weigh up how fear of communism during the Cold War shaped the path to independence in Southeast Asia.
Syllabus K330, Decolonisation and establishment of newly independent nations in Southeast Asia, Learning Outcomes. Assess how the Cold War politics affected the struggle for independence in Southeast Asia.
Make a guess
In September 1948 communists rebelled against the Republic at Madiun, and the Republic crushed the revolt. How do you think the USA reacted?
- It began to see the Republic as a non-communist partner worth backing.
- It sent troops to help the communist rebels.
- It backed the Dutch more strongly in their war against the Republic.
Show the answer
It began to see the Republic as a non-communist partner worth backing.
In the Cold War, the US feared communism in Asia. Madiun showed the Republic was not communist.
The Madiun Affair was a 1948 communist revolt in Indonesia; crushing it showed the USA the Republic was anti-communist and worth backing.
The Madiun Affair was a communist revolt against the Republic of Indonesia in September 1948. The Republic soon crushed it. This mattered for US policy: it showed the USA that the Republic was anti-communist. So the USA pressed the Dutch harder to make a deal with it.
Madiun is a town in East Java. On 18 September 1948, armed supporters of the Indonesian Communist Party (PKI) and its left-wing allies seized it. They set up their own government there.
The revolt grew out of a quarrel inside the Republic. Hatta's government, formed in January 1948, carried out the Renville agreement and began cutting the army. Left-wing parties opposed both, and the cuts hit their armed units hard. In August 1948 Musso returned and took charge of the PKI. He was a communist leader who had lived for years in the Soviet Union. He wanted the Republic to side with the Soviet Union.
The Republic struck back hard, even though it was still at war with the Dutch. On 19 September, Sukarno told Indonesians by radio to choose: him and Hatta, or Musso and the PKI. Republican troops, led by the Siliwangi Division, retook Madiun by 30 September. Musso was shot dead on 31 October. Amir Sjarifuddin, a former prime minister who had joined the revolt, was executed in December. About 35,000 people were arrested.
Madiun mattered to the USA because of the Cold War, the rivalry between the communist USSR and the USA. The USA feared communism spreading in Asia. It had been slow to press the Netherlands, an ally it needed in Europe. The Dutch also claimed the Republic was open to communist influence. Madiun proved the opposite: the Republic had crushed communists, not joined them.
US officials now saw Hatta's government as an anti-communist partner. They thought it should be made stronger, not destroyed. On 7 December 1948, the US government urged the Dutch to keep talking and praised Hatta's action against the revolt. On 19 December the Dutch attacked the Republic anyway. They were attacking the government the USA had just backed.
The USA then used its strongest lever: Marshall Plan aid, US money to rebuild Europe, which the Dutch needed. In March 1949, it warned the Dutch that this aid was at risk unless they settled. Madiun did not win independence on its own. US pressure worked because Indonesian guerrillas kept fighting.
Put these in order
Put these steps in order, from the Madiun revolt to the Dutch handover.
- The USA urges the Dutch to keep negotiating with Hatta's government.
- The Dutch attack and capture Sukarno and Hatta.
- Republican troops crush the revolt, and Musso is killed.
- The Dutch transfer sovereignty to a federal United States of Indonesia.
- The USA warns that Marshall Plan aid to the Netherlands is at risk.
- Communists seize the town of Madiun and set up their own government.
Show the answer
- Communists seize the town of Madiun and set up their own government. 18 September 1948: The revolt challenged the Republic while it was still at war with the Dutch.
- Republican troops crush the revolt, and Musso is killed. September to October 1948: By crushing communists, the Republic showed the USA it was anti-communist.
- The USA urges the Dutch to keep negotiating with Hatta's government. 7 December 1948: US officials now wanted Hatta's government strengthened, not destroyed.
- The Dutch attack and capture Sukarno and Hatta. 19 December 1948: The Dutch were now attacking the government the USA had just backed.
- The USA warns that Marshall Plan aid to the Netherlands is at risk. 31 March 1949: The Dutch needed the aid, so they agreed in May to restore the Republic's leaders and negotiate.
- The Dutch transfer sovereignty to a federal United States of Indonesia.
- 18 September 1948
- Communists seize Madiun, East Java; Republican troops retake it by 30 September.
- Musso
- PKI leader back from the Soviet Union; killed on 31 October 1948.
- US view
- Hatta's government is anti-communist, so strengthen it and press the Dutch.
Worked example: Using Madiun in a 10-mark essay
Question: 'US pressure was the main reason the Dutch transferred sovereignty in 1949.' How far do you agree?
- Point: Madiun made the USA willing to back the Republic against the Dutch.
- Evidence: communists seized Madiun on 18 September 1948, and the army retook it by 30 September.
- Explain: crushing communists made the Republic an anti-communist partner, so the Dutch attack of 19 December 1948 harmed US aims.
- Link: so in March 1949 the USA warned the Dutch about their aid. One explained factor earns L2; add another, such as resistance, for L3.
Watch out for this
The USA backed Indonesian independence from the start.
At first the USA was slow to press the Dutch, its European ally. After Madiun showed the Republic was anti-communist, the USA pushed much harder.
Check your understanding
Why did the Madiun revolt make the US more supportive of the Republic?
- It ended Dutch attacks on the Republic straight away.
- The Republic defeated the communists, showing it could be a non-communist partner.
- The Republic led the revolt to win Soviet and Chinese allies abroad.
Show the answer
The Republic defeated the communists, showing it could be a non-communist partner.
Yes. That mattered to the US during the Cold War.
Check your understanding
How did the Republic's leaders respond when communists seized Madiun in September 1948?
- Sukarno told Indonesians to choose him and Hatta over Musso, and the army crushed the revolt.
- They asked Dutch troops to put the revolt down for them.
- They gave Musso and the PKI places in the cabinet to end the revolt.
Show the answer
Sukarno told Indonesians to choose him and Hatta over Musso, and the army crushed the revolt.
Yes. Republican troops retook Madiun by 30 September, Musso was killed and about 35,000 people were arrested.