9478 / 2027
Quantum Physics overview

Lesson 4 of 12

One particle at a time: building a pattern

  • I can explain the wave evidence from electron diffraction and double-slit interference of single particles.Syllabus

    Syllabus 9478, 19(d). Explain the wave evidence from electron diffraction and double-slit interference of single particles.

  • I can apply superposition to position wavefunctions to explain single-particle interference and standing solutions in a box.Syllabus

    Syllabus 9478, 19(g). Apply superposition to position wavefunctions to explain single-particle interference and standing solutions in a box.

Make a guess. You are not marked.

Single photons pass one at a time through a double slit to a sensitive screen. Where do the first few photons land?

  1. At scattered single points; a fringe pattern builds up after many detections.
  2. As two faint bright bands, one behind each slit, from the very start.
  3. As a faint copy of the complete fringe pattern, spread over the screen at once.
Show the answer

At scattered single points; a fringe pattern builds up after many detections.

Each photon is detected at one point. Where it lands is random, but the probability is greatest where the two amplitudes add. Many detections together show the bright and dark fringes.

Each particle is detected at one point, but where it lands is a matter of chance. Many detections build up an interference pattern, which shows where the chance is high and where it is low.

In a two-slit experiment with a very weak source, only one particle is in the apparatus at a time. So the fringes are not caused by particles bumping into each other. Each single particle behaves as a wave that passes through both slits, then is detected at one point.

A detection dot shows where the particle was found. It does not show a path from the source to the screen.

First 20 detections

First 20 detectionsThe first 20 detections look scattered. The counts are made up for illustration, in nine bins 1 mm wide.Constructed illustrative detections-4-3-2-101234Detector position / mmBin edges run from -4.5 to +4.5 mm.Vertical placement is schematic.

A small sample says little. An empty bin does not mean the probability there is zero.

The same constructed run after 200 detections

The same constructed run after 200 detectionsAfter 200 detections, the same run shows bands where many particles arrive and gaps where few do. The counts are made up for illustration, in nine bins 1 mm wide.Constructed illustrative detections-4-3-2-101234Detector position / mmBin edges run from -4.5 to +4.5 mm.Vertical placement is schematic.

With more detections the pattern becomes clear. These are illustrative counts, not real data.

Count per equal-width bin after 200 detections

Count per equal-width bin after 200 detectionsA bar chart of the counts after 200 detections, in nine bins 1 mm wide. The middle bin has 88 counts, the bins 2 mm either side have 34 each, and the rest have 4 to 10.02040608010010-44-334-28-18808134243104Count in each 1.0 mm binDetector position / mm

Bar height is the count in each equal bin, not a probability density.

The first 20 detections look scattered. After 200 detections from the same run, bands appear. The bar chart shows the counts in each 1 mm bin.

Counts estimate probabilities

The table shows made-up counts in nine bins, each 1.0 mm wide, centred from -4 to +4 mm. They illustrate how a pattern builds up; they are not real data.

Illustrative counts in the same nine detector bins
Bin centre / mmFirst 20After 200
-4110
-314
-2334
-108
01088
+118
+2334
+304
+4110

The middle bin holds 88 of the 200 detections, so the chance of landing in that bin is about 88/200 = 0.44. That is the probability for the whole bin, from -0.5 to +0.5 mm, not for one exact point. An empty bin after only 20 detections does not mean the probability there is zero.

Paper 4 practice: spreadsheet

From counts to probabilities

Download the illustrative counts (CSV). The columns are the bin centre, left edge and right edge in mm, then the counts after 20 and after 200 detections, in A2:E10. The motion-data page shows how to import data.

First formulas after import
CellFormula
F2: bin width / mm=C2-B2
G2: early fraction=D2/SUM($D$2:$D$10)
H2: later fraction=E2/SUM($E$2:$E$10)
I2: later density / mm-1=H2/F2

Fill F2:I2 down to row 10. Check that the counts add up to 20 and 200, and that each fraction column adds up to 1. Draw bars over the real bin edges.

Check the middle bin

Its later fraction is 0.44. Divided by its 1.0 mm width, that is a density of 0.44 mm-1. Multiply the density by the width and you get back the probability, 0.44.

A real example. In 1989, Akira Tonomura and his team at Hitachi sent electrons one at a time through an electron version of the double slit. They filmed single electrons arriving one by one, as dots, and the dots slowly built up an interference pattern.

Do not say the electron splits in two, or that fringes come from electrons hitting each other. One electron at a time still builds the pattern. Each one is detected whole, at one point.

Check your understanding

Particles pass one at a time through a double slit. After 200 detections, 88 lie in a 1.0 mm bin at the centre of the screen. Which of these is the best estimate of the probability that the next particle lands in that bin?

  1. 88
  2. 0.44
  3. 0.11, one bin out of nine
Show the answer

0.44

The fraction of detections in the bin estimates its probability: 88/200 = 0.44. It is the probability for the whole bin, not for one point.