9477 / 2027

Lesson 2 of 8 / Evolution, species and phylogeny

Types of selection, and change by chance

How can you tell which process changed a population?

I can name the type of selection from its effect, and separate selection from genetic drift.

  • I can explain natural selection in evolution.Syllabus

    Syllabus 9477, Core 4(c). Explain natural selection in evolution.

About 6 min

Make a guess. You are not marked.

A storm kills 90% of a beetle population at random. Afterwards, one allele is far more common than before. What most likely changed its frequency?

  1. Selection: the allele must have helped beetles survive the storm.
  2. Chance: the survivors were a random sample of the population.
  3. Mutation: the storm made new copies of that allele.
Show the answer

Chance: the survivors were a random sample of the population.

The deaths were random, so the survivors' alleles differ from before by chance. This is a bottleneck, a kind of genetic drift.

The key idea

Directional selection shifts the mean, stabilising selection narrows the range and disruptive selection favours both extremes; genetic drift changes allele frequencies by chance, most strongly in small populations.

Explore the idea

Which phenotypes are favoured?

Number of individualsTrait value, such as beak depthBeforeAfter selection

One extreme is favoured. The whole curve moves, so the mean shifts over generations.

Invented curves. Genetic drift has no fixed shape: it changes allele frequencies by chance, most in small populations.

Explanation

Name the type of selection from its effect on a trait that varies, such as beak depth. Ask which phenotypes leave the most offspring. A phenotype is an observable feature.

In directional selection, one extreme is favoured, so the mean of the trait shifts that way over generations. For example, deeper beaks are favoured when only large, hard seeds are left. The spread of antibiotic resistance in bacteria is also directional selection.

In stabilising selection, the intermediate phenotype is favoured and both extremes are selected against. The mean stays the same and the variation narrows. In disruptive selection, both extremes are favoured over the intermediate, which can split a population into two forms.

Genetic drift is a change in allele frequency by chance. It does not depend on whether an allele is useful. It is strongest in small populations, where chance decides more of who breeds. An allele can be lost, or become the only allele, with no advantage at all.

Two events make drift strong. In the founder effect, a few individuals start a new population, for example on an island. They carry only a small sample of the original alleles. In a bottleneck, a disaster kills most of a population, and the survivors' allele frequencies differ by chance from before. Both reduce genetic diversity.

Keep the two processes apart. Examiners report a very common error: calling the change that selection causes "genetic drift". Selection is not random and adapts a population to its environment. Drift is random and need not.

Step by step
  1. 1

    Look at the distribution

    Which phenotypes leave more offspring: one extreme, the middle or both extremes?

  2. 2

    Name the selection

    Directional, stabilising or disruptive.

  3. 3

    Rule chance in or out

    In a small population, ask whether drift could explain the change.

Worked example

Work through the evidence

Thirty birds start a new population on an island. A harmless allele that is at 2% in the source population is at 20% on the island. Explain the change.

One way to explain it

The founders were a small, chance sample of the source population, so the allele was over-represented from the start. This is the founder effect, a form of genetic drift. Selection is not needed, because the allele gives no advantage.

Why this answer works
  • A harmless allele gives no advantage, so selection does not explain its rise.
  • Chance sampling matters most when a population is small.

Watch out for this

A student says: "Genetic drift is the change in allele frequency that natural selection produces." What is wrong with this?

Show the answer

Drift is a separate process. Allele frequencies change by chance, whether or not an allele helps; selection is the non-random part.

In the real world

Drought and finch beaks, Daphne Major, 1977

In 1977 a major drought hit Daphne Major, one of the Galapagos Islands. Peter and Rosemary Grant measured medium ground finches that died and finches that survived. In a sample of 50 of each, survivors had beaks 9.67 mm deep on average, against 9.11 mm for those that died, which suggests directional selection for deeper beaks.

Source: HHMI BioInteractive, Using BioInteractive Resources to Teach Mathematics and Statistics in Biology (data from Peter and Rosemary Grant)

Check your understanding

Snails with medium-thick shells survive best; very thin and very thick shells are selected against. What happens to shell thickness over generations?

  1. The mean stays similar and the range narrows.
  2. The mean shifts towards thicker shells over time.
  3. The population splits into thin and thick forms.
  4. The range widens while the mean stays similar.
Show the answer

The mean stays similar and the range narrows.

This is stabilising selection: the middle is favoured, so extremes become rarer.

Quick recall

Card 1 of 3. Answer in your head, then check.

How can you tell which process changed a population?

You can return to this lesson any time.