9477 / 2027

Lesson 8 of 8 / Evolution, species and phylogeny

Build a tree and date a split

How can a table of sequence differences give both a tree and a date?

I can build a tree from a difference table and estimate divergence dates with a molecular clock.

  • I can explain classification by shared characteristics and evolutionary relationship.Syllabus

    Syllabus 9477, Core 4(i). Explain classification by shared characteristics and evolutionary relationship.

  • I can explain genome sequence alignment and molecular phylogenetic evidence.Syllabus

    Syllabus 9477, Core 4(l). Explain genome sequence alignment and molecular phylogenetic evidence.

About 6 min

Make a guess. You are not marked.

In one gene, species A and B differ at 20 bases, and A and C at 80. If the gene changes at a steady rate, which pair shares the more recent common ancestor?

  1. Neither, because the order of splits cannot be known without a fossil of the ancestor.
  2. A and B, because fewer differences have built up since they split.
  3. A and C, because more differences show a closer relationship.
Show the answer

A and B, because fewer differences have built up since they split.

At a steady rate, differences build up with time, so the pair with fewer differences split more recently.

The key idea

Join the pair with the fewest differences first, then add the others in order; dividing differences by a rate calibrated from a dated split estimates when lineages diverged, if the rate stayed constant.

Explore the idea

Join the closest pair first

Invented differences in one 1,000-base gene
SpeciesABC
B24
C9696
D150150150
ABCD

Read the table first. Which pair has the fewest differences?

Explanation

A difference table gives the number of differences between each pair of species in one gene. To build a tree, join the two species with the fewest differences first, because they share the most recent common ancestor. Then join the next closest species to that pair, and continue until all are joined.

In an invented table for one 1,000-base gene, species A and B differ at 24 bases, A and C at 96, B and C at 96, and D differs from each of A, B and C at 150. A and B join first, then C joins the A-B branch, and D branches off earliest.

If fossils date one split, the differences give a rate of change, called a molecular clock. Suppose fossils show A and B diverged 4 million years ago. The rate is 24 differences / 4,000,000 years = 6 x 10^-6 differences per year for the pair. Both lineages have changed since the split, so each lineage changes at half this rate.

To date another split, divide its number of differences by the same pair rate. This assumes the rate stayed constant over time and in every lineage. It may not: generation time and selection can differ between lineages.

Examiners report two weak points. Candidates counted differences but did not link the number to time through a constant rate of mutation. Others suggested comparing DNA with plants that lived millions of years ago, which is not feasible; compare living relatives instead.

Step by step
  1. 1

    Join the closest pair

    Find the smallest number of differences.

  2. 2

    Add the next closest

    Join each remaining species in order of differences.

  3. 3

    Calibrate and date

    Rate = differences / time from a dated split; date = differences / rate.

Worked example

Work through the evidence

In one gene, A and B differ at 24 bases, and fossils show they split 4 million years ago, a pair rate of 6 x 10^-6 differences per year. C differs from A and B at 96 bases, and D differs from A, B and C at 150. When did C and D split from the others?

One way to explain it

C split from the A-B line about 96 / (6 x 10^-6) = 16 million years ago, and D about 150 / (6 x 10^-6) = 25 million years ago.

Why this answer works
  • Use the pair rate with the number of differences between the pair, not the rate per lineage.
  • Both dates assume the rate stayed constant.

Watch out for this

A student says: "To date a split, compare the DNA of a living species with DNA from its ancestor of millions of years ago." What is wrong with this?

Show the answer

Such ancient DNA is rarely available. Compare living relatives, count the differences and convert them to time with a rate from a dated split.

In the real world

Dating the origin of HIV-1, 2008

In 2008 M. Worobey and colleagues read HIV-1 sequences from a lymph node sample taken in 1960 in Leopoldville, now Kinshasa. With a sample from 1959, these dated sequences helped convert genetic differences into time. A molecular clock that allowed rates to vary dated the most recent common ancestor of the M group of HIV-1 to near the beginning of the twentieth century.

Source: Worobey and others (2008), Direct evidence of extensive diversity of HIV-1 in Kinshasa by 1960, Nature 455, 661-664

Check your understanding

Fossils show species X and Y split 3 million years ago, and they differ at 18 bases in a gene. X and Z differ at 54 bases. Assuming a constant rate, when did Z split from the X-Y line?

  1. About 54 million years ago
  2. About 18 million years ago
  3. About 9 million years ago
  4. About 1 million years ago
Show the answer

About 9 million years ago

The rate is 18 / 3,000,000 = 6 x 10^-6 per year, and 54 / (6 x 10^-6) = 9,000,000 years.

Quick recall

Card 1 of 3. Answer in your head, then check.

How can a table of sequence differences give both a tree and a date?

You can return to this lesson any time.